This sort of seems to be mentioned in a few places, but I couldn’t find a clear answer — a way to work around this, or “it’s coming” in the sidebar or the component, or “nope”, etc… I’ve enabled the experimental sidebar on my Discourse-hosted site. I get colored blocks next to my categories. And no…

Just dropping a quick note here, we’re working on making the category icons and tag icons theme components compatible with Sidebar in the short term. This should land by next week. Longer term though, we intend to make customizable icons for category or tags a core feature.

[image] Craig Constantine: I couldn’t find a clear answer — a way to work around this, or “it’s coming” in the sidebar or the component, or “nope”, etc… The current answer is that we don’t have any specific plans for this. There’s been some discussion about making category icons a first clas…

The category icons component overrides a core category link renderer to add its icons. The sidebar, for good reason, doesn’t use the same renderer, so we need to add a way to extend/override the sidebar category links in core before a component can do something here. Similar story for tags, but it’…

We’ve been talking internally about getting closer to parity of features between tags and categories, and to let tags be decorated with colors in the same way as categories, and to let both be decorated with icons. Differentiating tags and categories with colors and icons can make a big difference …

[image] Dave McClure: @craigconstantine - what would you expect the sidebar to look like when icons are used? would you expect the icons to have the category color in this scenario? The same as they do in the old-style ≡ menu? I flipped off enable-exp-sidebar, blew out my browser cash, refre…

[image] Craig Constantine: I flipped off enable-exp-sidebar, blew out my browser cash, refreshed To go back to the old way you also have to turn off the “enable experimental sidebar hamburger” setting.

derp …you are of course correct. Here’s a screenshot of how icons should appear next to categories, in the sidebar when category-style is none: [Screen Shot 2022-11-01 at 15.48.17]

re: category icons i don’t particularly care for them myself. i agree it would be clutter IMO. i was more addressing @craigconstantine ’s concerns because they were sort of available in the legacy menu.

Yeah, this may be an unrealistic and unnecessary suggestion. The colors in the sidebar match the category colors used in many places in the UI.

yea myself, i have no issue with those colored bullets (other than the lock icons, but i can code them out). just give me the ability to mod the community section and i’ll be chuffed. :slight_smile:

[image] Tobias Eigen: The colors in the sidebar match the category colors used in many places in the UI. Yes, but that isn’t same as purpose :wink: What ever. I just don’t believe users can and will identify categories per different colors, so I have disabled them where I can and otherwise I…

Ability to display category icons in sidebar

Support

Topic		Replies	Views
Add category icons in the sidebar Feature category-icons , sidebar	8	513	September 4, 2023
Can the background color in front of the navs in the sidebar be changed to a small icon? Support	14	330	July 14, 2024
Icons don't show up in the sidebar then the color isn't defined UX category-icons , completed	8	592	July 15, 2024
Category Icons don't show up in post text UX category-icons , completed	6	132	July 18, 2024
The sidebar doesn’t follow category style if none UX sidebar	6	429	April 23, 2023

Ability to display category icons in sidebar

Related topics