사이트 아카이빙 관련 조언

[jbrains (J. B. Rainsberger)]

I’m looking less for “how to” advice and more for strategy advice.

I intend to retire comments from a blog. I’ve been using Discourse to provide comments for that blog. I have comments that I don’t want to lose, but I also don’t want to merely convert existing comments into static HTML to include alongside the posts. I have in mind to rewrite old posts, integrating content from the comments into the new versions, and to do this gradually.

I infer that I want to archive the Discourse site, so that I can then serve it locally and browse it and grab content in an “as I need it” fashion to rewrite or edit a post. I’m curious whether anyone has any “better” suggestions for what to do in order to be able to mine these comments for content later. I’m leaving “better” up to your interpretation, because I’d like to take advantage of the creativity of the group. Please don’t ask me what kind of “better” I have in mind; I want your unfiltered ideas.

Many thanks.

[lindsey (Lindsey Fogle)]

안녕하세요 @jbrains — 이 주제가 더 적합한 카테고리라고 생각해서 #community-building으로 옮깁니다.

[NateDhaliwal]

Perhaps wayback machine?

[twofoursixeight]

Would this work for archiving your site?

A basic Discourse archival tool

For what it’s worth, I’ve written a minimum viable Python script that performs simple backup of post content using the API: GitHub - jamesob/discourse-archive: Provides a simple archive of Discourse content It’s pretty barebones, but should give someone a rough idea of how to generate a suitbable-for-public archive.

Might not be the best option, but this older discussion seems like a useful start.

[rishabh]

This reminds me of Mirroring a read-only mailing list in Discourse, but without the mailing list part.

@jbrains

I infer that I want to archive the Discourse site, so that I can then serve it locally and browse it and grab content in an “as I need it” fashion to rewrite or edit a post.

Maybe running the site in read-only mode or development mode on your network is the way to go?

Also if you only need to sift through post content and don’t need the Discourse UI, a simple Discourse Data Explorer query can let you download a csv/json file with the data that you can use other applications to search.

[jbrains (J. B. Rainsberger)]

@NateDhaliwal

Perhaps wayback machine?

I find this idea very interesting and creative, but I think I prefer to have the option to browse the comments offline easily.

@twofoursixeight

Would this work for archiving your site?

For what it’s worth, I’ve written a minimum viable Python script that performs simple backup of post content using the API: GitHub - jamesob/discourse-archive: Provides a simple archive of Discourse content It’s pretty barebones, but should give someone a rough idea of how to generate a suitbable-for-public archive.

Might not be the best option, but this older discussion seems like a useful start.

Maybe so. Thank you for the idea. I believe I used this to archive a community Discourse that I used as part of a training course. I then distributed the archive to the participants for their reference.

@rishabh

This reminds me of Mirroring a read-only mailing list in Discourse, but without the mailing list part.

@jbrains

I infer that I want to archive the Discourse site, so that I can then serve it locally and browse it and grab content in an “as I need it” fashion to rewrite or edit a post.

Maybe running the site in read-only mode or development mode on your network is the way to go?

Also if you only need to sift through post content and don’t need the Discourse UI, a simple Discourse Data Explorer query can let you download a csv/json file with the data that you can use other applications to search.

Aha! This is exactly the kind of thing that I was looking for. Thank you for pointing me to it. I’ll take a look.