Does anyone know if forum members will get an email every time there is a new comment on a topic in the Announcements category? Or will they only get an email about comments when they “Watch” a particular topic within the Announcements category?
AI-generated summary
In a discussion about email notifications for the Announcements category, ArcticF0xx asks whether members receive emails for every comment or only when they watch a topic. Falco explains that notification behavior depends on the category’s settings — options include default tracked, watched, watching first post, or normal. Since ArcticF0xx’s category is set to “Watching,” users receive emails for every comment, which Falco warns may lead to spam complaints. jomaxro suggests switching to “watching first post” to notify only for new topics, not replies. ArcticF0xx thanks both for the advice [6]. Later, alefattorini asks if this setting can be forced for all users by default. jomaxro confirms it’s possible via the site settings at /admin/site_settings/category/all_results?filter=default%20categories%20watching%20first%20post, advising caution since unsolicited emails may be flagged as spam. A screenshot is included to illustrate the setting.
Depends on how you configure your “Announcements” category, as we don’t ship one by default. You can set it to be default tracked, watched, watching first post, or normal (the default for all new categories).
Thanks, @Falco. We have it set to “Watching,” so everyone gets an email. Would that also mean they get emails for every single comment on each topic?
Yes, watching means being notified for every single post.
That is a bit uncommon and can lead to users flagging your emails as spam.
You likely want the “watching first post” notification option. That will email for post only, not comments.
Can I force this for every user by default?
You can, though keep in mind users receiving email they didn’t sign up may consider it spam.
Navigate to /admin/site_settings/category/all_results?filter=default%20categories%20watching%20first%20post on your site and add the category to the site setting. When you save the setting you’ll be prompted to apply it historically. To apply to all users, select yes.
