Users are discussing the limitations of Discourse’s anonymous posting feature, particularly when it comes to accessing members-only or group-restricted categories. jpalermo initiated the thread, noting that enabling anonymous mode revokes access to locked categories. codinghorror confirmed this is currently not supported. Jonathan5 and others explored potential workarounds, including using trust levels or plugins to auto-assign anonymous users to groups, but found these insufficient for private group access. JammyDodger proposed a workaround using an Anonymous group and category permissions, but acknowledged it doesn’t solve the core issue of granting anonymous users access to restricted areas (e.g., TL3 or semester-specific groups). Jonathan5 referenced a similar unresolved issue raised by Geoffrey_Challen, emphasizing that anonymous users lose group-based permissions — a critical problem for communities relying on granular access control. codinghorror concluded that the scenario is complex and carries risks, especially around unintended moderator actions. No current solution allows anonymous users to retain original group permissions while preserving privacy.
Hello; we are hosting a live chat in our Discourse community on the topic of making a career switch, and we’d like to enable our members to have the option of participating anonymously to protect their privacy given the chat topic. However, when I went to test out the anonymity feature, I found that I lost access to the members-only sections of our Discourse community – we are hosting this live chat in one of our members-only categories.
Is there any way that users can anonymize themselves while retaining their original permissions to access locked categories on Discourse?
Well, I don’t think anonymous posting is available yet! Though I didn’t make this site so @codinghorror or another staff member might be able to answer your question!
Anonymous posting is available to an extent - see Enable and configure anonymous mode - I just wondered whether it’s available for what the original poster termed “members-only” categories (categories which can’t be seen by all users).
Reading old topics again it seems like this wouldn’t need a plugin at all. For reference, here are two posts that mention the idea:
This approach could work for categories like the “Lounge” where access is based on trust level – you could set anonymous posting min trust level to the same as for viewing the category. It would mean, though, that fewer people could use anonymous mode in the first place.
But I can’t figure out a way to allow anonymous users to access private groups in any other circumstance
If I create an Anonymous group, and auto-enrol anyone with anon.[MySite] as their email, and then create a category where everyone can see and reply (but not create), and add the Anonymous group as see/reply/create, then that works for me? Everyone can see the category, but the ‘create topic’ button is greyed out unless you’re in the Anonymous group.
Edit: Nope. I see. You don’t want a eg TL1 anon having access to a TL3 area. Hmmm.
Thanks. I think that is a slightly different scenario. Your category is one where “everyone can see”, which includes the anonymous users. The category I have in mind is one which only members of a specified group can see, which does not include the anonymous users.
Exactly! Or an area that is only accessible to a specified group.