A discussion has started about making the “Bookmarks” view the default home page on Discourse sites. craigconstantine initially suggested this, as it’s an extremely useful view, and he’d love to land there instead of having to type ‘g’ ‘b’ every time. robotnjik supported this idea, mentioning that some of their users have also asked for this option.
There is a theme component that allows admins to choose the default homepage, but it’s not clear if users can choose their own homepage from their profile. dax provided links to relevant discussions and theme components.
merefield agreed that providing the choice natively would make sense, and a PR welcome. neounix suggested that admins should be able to select a set of bookmarks as the default home page, but merefield pointed out that this wouldn’t make sense, as bookmarks are individual to each user.
neounix clarified that the idea is to have a homepage of “featured topics” selected by admins, which is different from users’ bookmarks. merefield submitted a PR to support Bookmarks Discovery route as users’ preferred home and merefield announced that it was merged.
However, sam expressed some concerns about adding the Bookmarks view as the default home page, as it’s not technically a topic list anymore, but a special UI. codinghorror supported the spirit of the idea but agreed that this might not be the right implementation at the current time.
In my Preferences, for Interface, there’s a control for the Default Home Page. Is it possible to make that include the Bookmarks view?
…here in Meta, in a community where I’m just a regular user, and in my community where I’m a full admin, “Bookmarks” is not an option for the Def Home Page setting.
I think it’s an extremely useful view and I’ve love to land there rather than always having to type ‘g’ ‘b’ on every Discourse site.
There is a theme component that allow admins to choose the default homepage for all users, Allow Arbitrary Homepage (by Jay Pfaffman), but I’m not sure if users can choose the homepage from the user profile.
Actually agree with first two Posters. Providing the choice natively would make sense?
If admin has included Bookmarks discovery in the Top Menu setting in basic setup then to me it’s logical to include it in the user interface options? The two lists should be identical?
Actually I initially liked that but if you think about it, it doesn’t make sense. How can an admin select everyone’s bookmarks? They are individual to each user … imagine an admin deciding which users bookmarks appeared for each user? I can’t imagine it.
The idea is to have a homepage of bookmarks (featured topics) selected by admin(s). If you don’t like the term “bookmark”, you can call it “featured topics”. It is the same idea. A homepage can be selected which is composed of “selected topics” by the admins (versus the current limited set of options).
This idea, as I originally understood it, does not effect bookmarks by users (or anyone). So maybe the term “featured topics” is less confusing?
The idea (in my. mind) was not to select others bookmarks.
The idea is to have a homepage of bookmarks (featured topics) selected by admin(s). If you don’t like the term “bookmark”, you can call it “featured topics”. It is the same idea. A homepage can be selected which is composed of “selected topics” by the admins (versus the current limited set of options).
This idea, as I originally understood it, does not effect bookmarks by users (or anyone). So maybe the term “featured topics” is less confusing?
Is that not clear (now)? If not, I can explain more if unclear. Actually, I am not really “wed” to this idea, it just sounded useful for admins to be able to have a page of their own topics they want to feature on the home pages without “pinning” them.
Maybe it’s not a good idea? I do not want to hijack this thread, to be honest.
What do you mean by this ? Is there a shortcut I don’t know about ?
In your idea, if the topics are selected by the admin and if it’s the “default” page, pinning would indeed achieve approximately the same thing. I understood OP (+first answer) was/were talking of a view where each user would see his OWN bookmarks (or did I misunderstood ?)
FYI I’m about to submit a PR to support Bookmarks Discovery route as users preferred home, but having some interesting issues with the significant tests I’ve added to cover it which I’ll try and work with a team member to resolve. I’ll keep you updated.
I guess this is OK @sam this gets us one step closer to “you define your own custom homepage, which is this specific category plus this specific category plus this specific tag and that’s all”.
Tricky, cause we are moving away from the topic list bookmarks page to the /my/activity/bookmarks route. This is not technically a topic list anymore, it is a special UI.
Not sure I support adding this as default home page.