Can new users be 'Read Only' while their account gets approved by moderation?

AI-generated summary

The discussion revolves around whether new users can have read-only access until approved by an admin. Dylan_Russell asks how to allow new users to read content while restricting posting until approval. Falco suggests disabling the login required setting, but schleifer notes that this affects anonymous users, including search bots like Googlebot, which may not be desirable. Falco agrees that the use case isn’t fully clear. sam adds that the allow index in robots txt setting can control indexing if search engine visibility is a concern.

Hi there, title pretty much explains my question. Right now when new users are created they have to be approved my admin, but this working quite right for us. Ideally we’d like new users to have access to read-only forum, then once admin approves their account they can stop posting.

Just wondering how this should best be done! I’m not even sure if the Admin Approval feature is what we really need. Any suggestions on this is helpful.

Hmmm, if you disable the login required setting that is the effectively the same right?

Allowing anons and unapproved users expose the posts in the same way.

Googlebot is an anon, so I’d say the scope is still different.

It’s hard to give advice because you haven’t said what your goal is, just what you’re currently doing. Do you want to restrict all content? Or just limit who can post? What’s the motivation?

If blocking search bots is the objective, better to use the specific setting for that.

But as you said, OP didn’t explain the use case enough…

Note for the googlebot problem @Dylan_Russell remember we have the allow index in robots txt site setting, so you can still disable indexing here.