The discussion revolves around the feasibility and community reception of charging for plugins in the Discourse ecosystem. ti0 initiates the conversation, asking whether it’s acceptable to sell plugins and seeking guidance on the matter. RGJ responds by referencing past negative experiences, citing legal concerns about whether plugins are derivative works and the unprofessional conduct of a previous developer. ti0 appreciates the feedback and expresses a preference for the free model, considering donations as an alternative. pfaffman suggests a common approach: open-sourcing plugins while monetizing through support or customization services. neounix adds another model—creating a commercial third-party app and offering a free Discourse plugin to integrate with it. The consensus leans toward open-source plugins with alternative revenue models rather than direct sales.
Is it ok to charge for plugins in the Discourse community ? Are there any paid plugins out there ? I know the official Discourse hosting offers Business and Enterprise plugins, I am talking about plugin authors charging for plugins.
I am creating a plugin, and I would like to consider the option of either making it a paid plugin, or a donation-based plugin, or keep it free, depends on how the community responds. Just want to know my options, and curious how the community feels about this topic.
If charging is ok, how to go about this ? Any guides ?
Most people who are making a living on plugins do so by making general-purpose plugins open source and charging for support and/or further customization.
A similar business model @ti0 is to build a useful third party application like Slack, GitHub, Sentry, etc and then create and give away a Discourse plugin that integrates Discourse with your commercial 3rd party app.