Debate / deliberation plugin

AI-generated summary

The discussion is about finding a Debate / deliberation plugin for Discourse. Mirage is looking for a plugin that allows for a column for “Yes for…” arguments and a column for “No, because…” arguments, similar to this example. Mirage believes this feature would be useful for debates, as it would allow for a clear presentation of arguments, critical examination of opposing viewpoints, and foster intellectual growth. Mirage provides another example and asks if it’s possible to have the same thing with Discourse. Mirage mentions that the Discourse Post Voting plugin partially solves the problem, but is missing the debate section with YES and NO columns.

Hello,
Do you know a plugin to do this on Discourse in a topic?


Source: CaptainFact

A column for argument “Yes for…”
A column for argument “No, because…”

this May be useful for debate:

  • A column dedicated to presenting arguments in favor of a particular position can be immensely useful in fostering constructive debates.
  • Such a column provides a platform for proponents to articulate their ideas, allowing for a clear and structured presentation of their supporting points.
  • It enables individuals to build a persuasive case by organizing their thoughts and providing logical reasoning behind their stance.
  • By offering a designated space for pro arguments, it ensures that the positive aspects of a topic are thoroughly explored and acknowledged.
  • It encourages participants to critically analyze their position, fostering intellectual growth and a deeper understanding of the subject matter.
  • Conversely, having a column dedicated to counterarguments, labeled “No, because…” can greatly enhance the quality of debates.
  • This column allows for the critical examination of opposing viewpoints, promoting a more comprehensive and well-rounded discussion.
  • It encourages participants to consider alternative perspectives and challenges them to address potential flaws in their own arguments.
  • By actively engaging with opposing viewpoints, individuals are prompted to strengthen their position through research, evidence, and sound reasoning.
  • Including a “No, because…” column fosters intellectual humility and demonstrates a commitment to open-mindedness, facilitating a more enriching debate experience.

Thanks

7 Likes

Other samples (UP)
https://www.capital.fr/espace-debat/debat/avez-vous-deja-utilise-votre-cpf-pour-fin

Can we have the same thing with discourse?

The job is partially done with this plugin; the only missing part is the debate section, with YES and NO columns.