In a support thread titled ‘Disable Reply as linked topic and / or Continuing the discussion from…’, Kat_F raises concerns about users misusing the ‘Reply as Linked Topic’ feature to bypass section-specific rules — such as one-post-per-user limits — and move discussions into inappropriate categories. This becomes problematic as the feature gains wider awareness, and moderation becomes burdensome since new topics require approval. pfaffman questions the intent, suggesting that if users want to discuss topics, restricting them may be counterproductive, and notes that even if the ‘new topic’ link is hidden via CSS, users can still circumvent restrictions by manually creating topics elsewhere with links or rephrased content. Kat_F clarifies that the core issue is not discussion itself, but the circumvention of section rules and the reduced visibility of linked topics, which are harder to track without manually scrolling through sections. The thread seeks solutions to either disable the feature in specific areas or remove it entirely to maintain forum structure and moderation efficiency.
Disable Reply as linked topic and / or Continuing the discussion from …
We have our forum set up where different sections / areas have different uses and different rules. Usually that works out well, except when a user uses ‘Reply as Linked Topic’ to move the discussion into a different area. Matters get worse when the ability to do this becomes general knowledge.
Is there a way to 1) disable the Reply as Linked Topic in a specific area or 2) remove the option altogether? Currently we have new topics subject to mod approval, but that’s a lot of extra work.
So people want to have discussions but you don’t want them to?
You can hide the “new topic” link in the modal with CSS, but what’s to stop someone from just starting a new topic about the Forbidden Issue in the categories that they can create topics in, either by including a link to the thing they want to talk about or just starting a new topic on that issue?
The issue is them using the linked topic and bypassing the section’s restrictions of one post per user per thread / section. The way the linked threads work make it harder to find them without directly scrolling the section.