Domain.com/bookmarks is showing domain.com/u/user/activity/bookmarks-with-reminders

AI-generated summary

Users reported a bug where navigating to domain.com/bookmarks redirected them to domain.com/u/user/activity/bookmarks-with-reminders instead of the frontpage filtered by bookmarks, as it previously did. exetico explained that some users rely on browser bookmarks to access the filtered topic list and found the change disruptive. Although the new page offers useful features like reminder details and quick actions, users preferred the original behavior for viewing new updates in bookmarked topics. martin initially defended the redirect but later agreed to revert it after discussion with sam and user feedback. exetico clarified users want to see new posts in bookmarked topics, not return to specific bookmarked posts. riking confirmed this understanding. martin committed to restoring the original behavior, which was successfully implemented, prompting exetico to confirm the fix and suggest closing the topic. The issue was resolved by prioritizing user preference for the frontpage bookmark filter over the profile activity page.

Hi,

A few of our users are using bookmarks (Yep, browser-bookmarks is still a thing, apparently), to the bookmark-filtering on the frontpage.

Normally the user would use his browser-bookmark (pointing at domain.com/bookmarks), to visit the Frontpage, filtered by bookmarks.

But after our last rebuild/update of the base (Discourse), the user is now ending on the Activity > Bookmarks-page:
domain.com/u/user/activity/bookmarks-with-reminders

By selecting “Bookmarks” on the frontpage, t’s still showing as domain.com/bookmarks in the browser address-bar.

However, refreshing the page, or browsing manually to the page, is forwarding the user to User-page > Acticity > Bookmarks, instead of our frontpage, with the “Bookmarks”-filter in use.

I’m not sure, if it’s related to this change:

We’ve just rebuildet to the latest version aka. 2.5.0.beta3 ( 0ae504aece ).

I’m not sure if this is actually a bug, or just changed “by design”, but we would like, to at least, have the option for both things :slight_smile:

Our current “top menu” settings-value is, as shown below:

2 likes

We will be cleaning this up this week. Hold tight.

4 likes

Hi.

How did it go? It’s still a problem, om our site - and I’ve just updated it to the latest build.

1 like

Hi Tobias,

@sam and I discussed this last week, and decided to keep the /bookmarks URL redirected to the new page because it shows details of the reminder time and bookmark name and provides quick actions for the bookmarks (delete, edit). Is there any particular reason the /bookmarks URL showing the front page filtered by bookmarks is more useful for you?

2 likes

Hi Martin

A few of our users a happy with the topic-overview, filtered by bookmarks, and they reported is as a bug to me.

It’s fine to redirect the ‘profile’ bookmark page, but please allow an alternative, so they can use their browser favorite, to navigate to the topic-list, filtered by their bookmarks. :folded_hands: They like it that way, and i actually fully understand them.

1 like

To clarify, these users are genuinely looking for new updates in topics I have bookmarked, and not to go back to the bookmarked post, correct?

3 likes

Correct, Kane. They are looking for new posts, and sometimes like to filter the topics, so only bookmarked subjects are shown (Just like they normally are, by going to our Frontpage > click on “Bookmarks”)

I’ll point out that i really like all the other changes, for the Bookmark-part! It’s really nice :slight_smile: This is our only problem with the new implementation, which has been reported by a few users.

3 likes

I am going to change this this week, so the /bookmarks goes to the original list.

5 likes

Thanks Martin. It’s now working, as it should :slight_smile: !

Now that it’s posted in “Bugs”, fell free to close this topic.

2 likes