게시글을 수정하면 이전 글로 돌아가는 문제 (다시)

[gingerbeardman (matt sephton)]

Previously

Editing a comment takes me back 20 posts in Discourse Hub app

Reply to topic Note what number reply you are Edit comment and save Observe jump back 20 posts Each subsequent edit jumps back a further 20 posts.

Today I just edited post 135 in a thread and it took me back 20 posts (as previously reported) but the post number at the bottom said 134/135.

After editing I saw this:

Going to the bottom to see the post I was editing (135) showed this:

The post it showed me was actually 115:

[codinghorror (Jeff Atwood)]

So to be clear what are the repro steps?

[gingerbeardman (matt sephton)]

Good question.

I’m still trying to reproduce it. Trying to remember if I did anything in particular during this edit.

A normal edit works OK.

[gingerbeardman (matt sephton)]

This is also happening when editing a DM in a long DM thread.

[codinghorror (Jeff Atwood)]

Ok, so what are the specific repro steps?

[gingerbeardman (matt sephton)]

The same as the old closed issue linked in the OP, but for DM view rather than Topic view.

[gingerbeardman (matt sephton)]

I’m also still seeing the original linked issue after editing a post. Same repro steps.

retrogameboards.com running 2.8.0beta2

[sam (Sam Saffron)]

Just confirming, this issue is specific to Safari iOS? Does not happen in Firefox / Chrome?

[gingerbeardman (matt sephton)]

This is still happening BTW.

[codinghorror (Jeff Atwood)]

I have experienced this as well, though I don’t have a specific repro.

[gingerbeardman (matt sephton)]

I’m still getting this. First reported in 2020.

Help me Obi-wan

[gingerbeardman (matt sephton)]

Still getting this.

It’s so annoying, like a scratch on a vinyl or CD that makes the audio skip back a bit. Then you have to find your place again.

[gingerbeardman (matt sephton)]

Still happening

[gingerbeardman (matt sephton)]

Hello!

Yes, this is still happening.

First reported November 2020.

[sam (Sam Saffron)]

Hmm, could this be somehow related to:

Modal input fields cause page jump to top of the page

Hello This is a long-standing issue that occurs in the topic when you try to type something into a modal input field. It always jumps to the top of the page, which results in an infinite load until it reaches post 1. It’s still an issue with the Glimmer Post Stream. It makes very difficult to move posts to another topic because the modal also jumps while loading, other write related process and it also causes problems with the new discourse reaction feature, which opens the emoji…

[gingerbeardman (matt sephton)]

Seems like a good chance

Unlikely, because the code for that bug was introduced after this one was first reported.

[pmusaraj (Penar Musaraj)]

I have a nagging bug for a long time when opening/closing topics that are assigned. It’s a much narrower use case, very much not what the report here is about, but there’s a slim chance the underlying issue is the same.

Here’s the PR for the other issue: DEV: Fix a rare bug where topic scrolls to OP unexpectedly by pmusaraj · Pull Request #34713 · discourse/discourse · GitHub, its repro steps are quite different, they’re related to the assign plugin (PR has specifics). But maybe, maybe… the fix can do something for your use case as well. One can always hope!

[gingerbeardman (matt sephton)]

There’s nothing I can do with this info. But I’m hopeful

[gingerbeardman (matt sephton)]

Anything I can do to help get this one licked?

It’s the final boss of bugs.