The discussion revolves around the need for edit approval in a forum system, where users can edit posts after initial moderator approval without further oversight. jordan1909 highlights this as a gap in moderation, as approved posts can be freely edited. pfaffman suggests using existing settings like editing grace period and post edit time limit to control editing, but jordan1909 clarifies that these don’t address the core issue of requiring moderator approval for edits. sam notes that implementing such a system is complex and would likely require a plugin, as it’s not currently planned for core, though the system is extensible. jordan1909 acknowledges this and decides to explore plugin development.
Is there any way to require an edit to be approved by an admin/mod as well?
We currently require utilize moderator approval required if TL < 3. It works fine for the initial submission however say a user submits a post, then a moderator approves it. The user is completely free to go an edit that post with no restriction. There is no subsequent approval required.
Are there any thoughts to adding this functionality? I see this as a pretty big gap in the current moderation/approval functionality. This window would essentially allow a user to say whatever with no restrictions once the initial post is approved.
I do see those however that doesn’t necessarily hit the root issue. Users should be able to edit their posts however a new moderation item such as: post edited should require mod approval.
Warning, I built a system similar to this at Stack Overflow and it took multiple months to get all the polish right. It was pretty large scale and involved anonymous edits as well, so it may be a bit bigger than what a basic plugin needs.
We are not particularly keen about adding this to core for now, but it can be a plugin for sure and core should provide the extensibility require to implement it.