Action post on split topic

AI-generated summary

In a discussion about improving visibility of moderator actions when splitting topics in Discourse, ChrisBeach proposes adding a prominent notice to the destination topic to clarify that it was created via a split — not by the original poster starting a new topic. codinghorror counters that the existing two-way link at the bottom of the destination topic is sufficient and that adding a banner would be redundant and overly prominent, calling it a “giant billboard.” ChrisBeach insists the current link is too subtle, especially since the original post may not read like a proper topic opener, potentially misleading readers. wolftune supports ChrisBeach, noting that moderator-initiated splits should be at least as visible as user-initiated “reply as new topic” actions, and finds the “giant billboard” criticism exaggerated. The debate centers on balancing clarity for readers against interface minimalism, with advocates arguing that moderator actions deserve clear visual acknowledgment to avoid misinterpretation of topic origins.

When a moderator splits a topic, the source topic gets a nice action message to make it clear what’s happened. However, it’s less clear to readers of the destination topic.

I propose Discourse shows something like this:

3 Likes

Not needed, there is a traditional two way link already, as we’ve always done in Discourse. A link at the top would be redundant.

Proof:

results in..

.. at the bottom of the destination topic, like all two-way links.

You’re making an editorial decision that you would prefer that to be on a giant billboard.

2 Likes

Yes, I’d like my modding action to be made clearer.

Bear in mind that the author of the post that’s been split may not have phrased their post in the way you would phrase the opening post of a topic.

Without a visible mod action, it simply looks as though the poster has created a new topic, which isn’t accurate (although, yes, there is a small link shown underneath the new topic)

3 Likes

I didn’t find this post initially when I revived the same issue here: Splitting a topic and moving replies to a new topic - #6 by wolftune

I’m not seeing any justification for why a moderator action splitting a topic should be less apparent than when a poster chooses to reply-as-new-topic. It seems quite hyperbolic to consider the proposed visual above in this topic to be a “giant billboard”.

2 Likes