Forum stats and admin dashboard should be admin only

AI-generated summary

A discussion started about whether forum statistics and the admin dashboard should be admin-only. AstonJ believes mods shouldn’t be able to see stats, but itsbhanusharma disagrees, citing the importance of mods being able to see the impact of their efforts in building the community. sam agrees with itsbhanusharma and has no intention of changing the current setup, which allows mods to see stats. However, sam and mcwumbly also discuss potential future developments, such as a “dashboard v2/3” and the ability to grant mods access to run data explorer reports. Additionally, tobiaseigen suggests that it could be beneficial to show stats to non-mods on a group basis, as some users may be interested in stats without needing moderator privileges.

Not sure why anyone would have difficulty understanding the stats tbh. Also, not sure why mods are able to see them anyway - forum statistics should be admin-only.

2 Likes

This is now turning into a community type of topic so I won’t mind if someone can split these into a separate topic.

what I understand from the discourse philosophy is that moderators are the real heroes in the community. They look after everything that is happening around whereas Admins are meant to take care of the technical side of things. I don’t think it would be a good idea not to let them see if their efforts to build a community are actually working or not.

8 Likes

I agree with @itsbhanusharma we have no intention to change it so forum stats are disabled for mods.

Long term … maybe … maybe if there is a stronger concept of category moderation this will become a thing.

In the near/medium future I oppose even to a site setting that enables hiding reports to mods, it would have to be a strong demand from a customer to change my mind here.

4 Likes

I’m looking forward to the opposite – being able to grant access for mods to run data explorer reports from the dashboard.

7 Likes

Long term I see “dashboard v2/3” allowing you to compose panels as you wish, and sourcing panels from data explorer.

Adding reports from data explorer seems like a great little stepping stone (as is a “reports index” page)

10 Likes

I could also see a benefit to being able to show the stats to non mods, say on a group basis. We have colleagues who care about stats and ask about them, but they do not need the moderator privileges.

6 Likes