Global mute user

AI-generated summary

A user ddf requested a “global mute” feature, where muted users can still post but remain invisible to others — essentially a shadowban. justin responded that Discourse does not support shadowbanning, preferring direct moderation and progressive consequences like warnings or bans. Mevo shared a link to a Discourse shadowban plugin, noting it may not be functional and that ignoring users is possible but requires Trust Level 2. DiscourseMetrics echoed the need for shadowbanning to deter persistent trolls who evade bans via new accounts/IPs, but confirmed the linked plugin doesn’t work — posts remain visible. The thread highlights demand for a stealth moderation tool, though Discourse’s official stance favors transparency and escalating penalties over hidden silencing.

I’m looking for global mute to user. That mean if someone get global muted by admin, him still can post reply or creat new topic but nobody can see him just like every mute him.

Is this possible or not?

1 Like

This sounds a lot like shadowbanning, which we don’t have a feature for performing. We find it better to address problematic behavior with individuals directly and use progressive consequences (warnings, suspensions, bans) if behavior does not correct.

5 Likes

I’ve come across this thread on the forum; which may be of interest to you: Discourse Shadowban
I don’t know if it works or works well. I guess you’ll have to try it.

EDIT: And if you’re just talking of ignoring a user, I understand according to what I’ve read that it’s a functionality embedded in Discourse (but you seem to need to be TL2, which I am not, so I don’t see the possibility to do it here).

I have a few trolls that get banned but return using new IPs, emails and so on.

If I could shadowban them they would waste a lot of time posting without their posts ever being read. This would be very useful.

The shadowban plugin linked to above does not work, posts are not hidden.

1 Like