Google will be treating nofollow links differently

AI-generated summary

Google announced it will treat the rel="nofollow" attribute as a hint rather than a signal, introducing new hints: ugc for user-generated content and sponsored for paid links. This change addresses the overuse of nofollow in CMS platforms, which previously undermined PageRank. The discussion covers implementation details, including combining attributes like rel="nofollow ugc" for backward compatibility. While Google is the primary focus, other search engines like Baidu and Yandex also support nofollow, with Bing treating it as a hint. The conversation includes a request for Discourse to adopt the new nofollow ugc attribute, which was later implemented. A bug was identified where ugc was missing from external links, but it was fixed in a subsequent update, ensuring links now correctly use nofollow ugc.

Google announced that it will not be treating the rel="nofollow" attribute as a signal any more, but as a hint. The background is that so many CMS’es are designating every link as nofollow.

They’re introducing two new hints: ugc for user generated content and sponsored for paid links.
For the UGC, they’re explicitly mentioning forums.

My opinion is that this is a big step forward, since the vast use of nofollow was killing the idea behind PageRank.

Full announcement here: https://webmasters.googleblog.com/2019/09/evolving-nofollow-new-ways-to-identify.html

15 likes

Changing the code to use “nofollow ugc” seems like a fairly straightforward and safe thing for Discourse to do.

The above is my personal opinion and not necessarily that of Google, LLC

3 likes

It it valid to use both? Should it just be “ugc” now? I am unclear.

From that blog’s FAQ:

Can I use more than one rel value on a link?
Yes, you can use more than one rel value on a link. For example, rel=“ugc sponsored” is a perfectly valid attribute which hints that the link came from user-generated content and is sponsored. It’s also valid to use nofollow with the new attributes – such as rel=“nofollow ugc” – if you wish to be backwards-compatible with services that don’t support the new attributes.

3 likes

What “services” support nofollow other than Google?

2 likes

Baidu, Yandex supports nofollow

Bing, as a hint

https://twitter.com/facan/status/1171477716673032192

8 likes

Can you assign this @eviltrout? I assume it is a very very simple change, almost a copyedit?

4 likes

Hey @Roman this is probably an easy one, please take a look!

3 likes

We’re now using nofollow ugc:

https://review.discourse.org/t/feature-use-the-ugc-rel-attribute-alongside-nofollow/6173

Latest Onebox version is using it too:

https://review.discourse.org/t/feature-use-the-ugc-rel-attribute/6170

11 likes

On 2.6.0.beta2 I’m getting rel="nofollow noopener" with no ugc attribute for external links. Anyone else?

Edit: Looked for a recent link posted on meta. Seems that it’s also the case here: What is this line for in a Discourse forum's RSS feed? - #4 by Terrapop

Not seeing the ugc attribute either, will take a look.

3 likes

Fixed here:

https://review.discourse.org/t/fix-make-sure-rel-attributes-are-correctly-set-10645/15145

Links will correctly use nofollow ugc now.

3 likes