How many votes should I give to users/trust levels

AI-generated summary

In a discussion about allocating votes to users by trust level on a developer-focused Discourse forum, Gaby_Rojas seeks advice on whether 4 votes for Trust Level 1 is sufficient or if higher allocations (up to 100) are better to reflect community voice. ondrej welcomes them and suggests a tiered system (TL0=2, TL1=5, TL2=10, TL3=15, TL4=20), cautioning that too many votes may lead to users voting indiscriminately. Gaby_Rojas clarifies their goal is to surface top community-requested features and considers increasing votes, especially for TL4 (currently capped at 10). Falco advises keeping vote counts low (TL0=1, TL1=2, TL2=3, TL3=5) to encourage thoughtful voting, noting that votes should be recycled as features are implemented, allowing users to reallocate them to newer requests. The consensus leans toward moderation: fewer votes promote meaningful engagement, while higher allocations risk diluting the value of each vote. Community size, feature turnover, and team capacity are key factors in determining optimal vote distribution.

Hi there,

We recently launched Discourse for our community and we enabled the vote plugin for users to vote for features. We are not sure how many votes we should give each user across trust levels. Does anyone have any experience around it? Is 4 votes to Trust Level 1 enough? Should it be more? 10, 20?

5 likes

Welcome to meta @Gaby_Rojas!:tada:

It depends what you want. What type of forum is it?

I normally do

TL0 = 2
TL1 = 5
TL2 = 10
TL3 = 15
TL4 = 20


I also tend to sometimes adjust them when I need to.

Remember that a vote shows what a member truly wants to see. So if they have many votes they will not consider what is important and use them all without thinking.

7 likes

Thank you @ondrej!

Our forum is for developers where they can submit feature requests. We want to show the community voice with the number of votes each feature receives, so we wonder if we should give them more votes. Right now the max is for TL4 with 10. We were even considering giving 100 votes.

1 like

You need to evaluate your community numbers. Take into consideration, that while new features come into fruition, old needs may not be applicable anymore. Also, you need to consider how many features you development team can work at the same time.

I would suggest keeping the numbers very low, like for example:

  • TL0: 1
  • TL1: 2
  • TL2: 3
  • TL3: 5

As your team close the topics of already implemented features, the votes are given back and your active users can now vote on the new features they want to see.

4 likes