I mostly think that importing passwords from a legacy forum is a Bad Idea. There are almost certainly a bunch of horrible passwords and it seems like making people change their password when they get a shiny new forum is a fine idea, but it seems that people want to do that anyway. There’s a plugin…

I think it’s fine to always import previous password hashes & salts. It’s just text, so that won’t take too much space. That way, people who want to allow their users to use their previous password can just add the linked plugin and be done.

Hi all. I am trying to migrate a forum from discuz x to discourse (v2.0.0.beta4), but running the corresponding import script results creating users 1 / 242 ( 0.4%) /home/localadmin/.rbenv/versions/2.4.2/lib/ruby/gems/2.4.0/gems/activemodel-5.1.4/lib/active_model/attribute_assignment.rb:48:in _…

Change it to password instead of import_pass. Or, if you’re not going to use the migrate-passwords plugin, just comment out or delete that line.

Changing it to password will probably not do the trick, because there is a separate salt field a few lines below. It should probably be something like password: user['password_hash']+':'+user['salt'] and then delete the lines import_pass: user['password_hash'], and salt: user['salt'],

[image] RGJ: because there is a separate salt field a few lines below. Oops! Thanks, Richard. @pmule , if you want imported passwords to work, you should pay attention to this!

Thanks. Now the import_users passed, but now it failed on import_categories when executing raw = process_discuzx_post(row['rules'], nil) if @bbcode_to_md raw = raw.bbcode_to_md(false) rescue raw end category.topic.posts.first.update_attribute(:raw, raw) wi…

Importer support for migrated passwords

Development

codinghorror (Jeff Atwood) Septembre 22, 2017, 6:51 2

Maybe include it but default it to off? Explain the downsides in the place where you would enable it?

Sujet		Réponses	Vues
Migrated password hashes support Plugin	34	12847	Juin 2, 2026
Handling user passwords when importing from another forum software? Product Support	3	3519	Octobre 25, 2016
Importing from phpBB Migration phpbb	19	3060	Mars 13, 2022
Drupal password migrate into Discourse with discourse-migrate-password plugin Migration	4	877	Février 15, 2024
Cannot login to dev instance with imported user Development	5	1632	Février 7, 2018

Importer support for migrated passwords

Sujets connexes