תצוגה לא עקבית של שם מלא ושם משתמש

סיכום מבוסס בינה מלאכותית

The discussion centers on inconsistencies in how full names and usernames are displayed across Discourse’s UI, despite user settings that prioritize full names. reclaimedpress reports that while full names appear correctly on posts, profiles, and user cards, they are inconsistently replaced by usernames in the notification menu, badges, user directory, and profile “most liked” sections. codinghorror supports fixing the user directory and profile sections and suggests assigning the task to @sam. techAPJ later confirms the fix via a commit that ensures consistency in the user directory, user summary, badge detail, and group detail pages. However, they note that space constraints in notifications justify keeping only the username there. downey asks if the design choice to hide full names when identical to usernames should be revisited, to which techAPJ responds that a separate topic would be needed for feedback. jerry0 raises a related concern about inconsistent group full name vs. groupname display, referencing an older topic; techAPJ replies there, indicating it may already be addressed. The thread highlights a focused UX improvement with partial resolution and lingering questions around design consistency for both users and groups.

I have the following settings enabled:

  • Full name is a required field of a user’s profile.
  • Show the user’s full name on their profile, user card, and emails. Disable to hide full name everywhere.
  • Show a user’s full name on their posts in addition to their @username.

And this disabled:

  • Show username first on user page, user card and posts (when disabled name is shown first)

On posts, the About page, user bios, user cards: this is respected.

In the notification/user menu, badges listings, user directory, and in user profiles “most liked” and other like sections, the username is given priority.

6 לייקים

I can definitely support the user directory and user profile here, probably fairly easy to do if you want to assign it @sam?

3 לייקים

Fixed via:

https://github.com/discourse/discourse/commit/3eb769d03b5f46f9204a7a7282a34a179de96f21

The above commit ensures consistency on following pages:

  • user directory
  • user summary
  • badge detail
  • group detail

We don’t have enough space in notifications to show user full name as well. We only show username there and I believe it should be left as is.

4 לייקים

Thanks for this @techAPJ!

Maybe it’s too far related from this topic, but is there any appetite to revisit the “don’t show the user’s full name if it’s the same characters as the username” design choice?

לייק 1

@codinghorror and @techAPJ this is fab, thank you.

I’ve reported similar issues (more serious) with regard to the inconsistent display of the Group Full Name and groupname over the years, I wonder if this can be looked at?

Labelling group inboxes with group full names - feature - Discourse Meta

EDIT: this may have been fixed already - if so sorry, please ignore. I’m going to have to done some testing.

לייק 1

I am not sure about that. There needs to a separate topic to gather feedback regarding that.

I just posted a reply on that topic.

3 לייקים

This topic was automatically closed after 20 hours. New replies are no longer allowed.