A word of caution. I admin an established community which has been using discourse for three years. We have seen an uptick in applications to register, which we screen carefully. But we have also seen a significant uptick in malicious applications. Practice online hygiene too.
AI-generated summary
In a discussion titled “Increase in malicious accounts amid COVID-19,” robbie.morrison shares that their established community, using Discourse for three years, has seen a significant rise in suspicious registration attempts, prompting stricter admin review policies. Previously, users could sign on automatically but required approval for their first post; now, all new users are manually reviewed — especially those with ISP or Gmail accounts, who receive a screening email. Responses range from legitimate to copied text or silence, leading to rejections via the “Delete and Block User” button. Motivations vary: some appear to be viral marketers or sock-puppets promoting agendas like nuclear power or discrediting wind farms. Others may simply be shy participants deterred by screening. codinghorror suggests the perceived uptick may stem from recent Discourse updates that now route spammy signups into review queues, implying no actual increase once backlog is cleared. robbie.morrison counters that the rise in suspicious applications is real and necessitates vigilance — including gating video-conference access via private topics to prevent unauthorized recording and misuse. They stress the growing importance of maintaining clean, secure online communities, even if it risks losing genuinely interested users as collateral damage.
I think I know what you’re referring to – those spammy (hey, I think I’ll fill out my profile but spend zero time reading) signups have always been there, it’s only in a very recent version of Discourse that we started pushing them through the review system.
So there isn’t actually an uptick, at least once you work through the backlog.
The site used to allow anyone to sign‑on automatically but require that their first posting be approved. About eight months ago we changed that policy. We now require all new user registrations to be reviewed by an admin (that authority may also extend to moderators?). We wave through anyone with a university or institutional email account of course. But those with an ISP email account, including gmail, get a dedicated email asking about their interest in the field.
Several things happen. We get a clearly legitimate and entirely sensible reply. Or some text copied from the internet — which we do not accept of course. Or no rely, in which case we reject the application via the Delete and Block User button after a week or so.
It is hard to assign motivation. A minority of rejected applications would fall under viral marketing — people who wish to sell things like virtual blackboard software to a receptive audience. Before we started screening, we had three individuals sign‑on and add “regular bloke” pictures to their profiles, such as standing in front of off‑road vehicles — completely inappropriate and perhaps sock‑puppets building online personas, possibly to run down wind farms or advocate nuclear power (our forum covers energy policy). I would guess some would be people wishing to follow our discussion but are too shy to answer our screening emails — which is a pity and counts as collateral damage.
Irrespective, I think it is becoming increasingly important to keep online communities clean. As just one example, we can now gate‑keep our video‑conferences by displaying the attendance password in a private topic. Otherwise, uncontrolled attendees can locally record the session and make malicious use of those recordings — that said, I cannot cite an example of that happening but I guess it has.
To conclude, I would say there is definitely an uptick in suspicious new user applications which we now review carefully and act on accordingly.