Issue with category permissions only for moderators

AI-generated summary

A user reports an issue with category permissions for moderators in Discourse v2.3.0.beta8, where moderators cannot create topics in a category they are permitted to access, despite having the correct permissions. The issue occurs when moderators are added via the setup wizard. After testing, another user confirms the problem, noting that moderators added this way do not appear in the moderators or staff groups, preventing them from seeing the category. A workaround is suggested: revoking and re-assigning moderator status. The issue has been acknowledged, and a fix has been proposed in a pull request by a developer nbianca.

I dont know if this issue is for other type of users…but here are steps to reproduce for moderators.

  1. Install new forum and add few moderators at setup.
  2. Create a category and give permission to post only for moderators.
  3. Login as a moderator and try to post. New Topic option is disabled for moderators even though permission are available for them.
  4. Now login as a admin and revoke moderator permission and give him back again(instantly).
  5. Login as a moderator, now you will see New Topic option.

It is not a blocking issue but please look into this. thanks!

Which version are you running?

I’m using latest v2.3.0.beta8

@sat, I’m not able to reproduce this. I attempted the following:

  1. Navigated to try.discourse.org and logged in as admin.
  2. Opened the create category modal.
  3. Gave the category a name
  4. Switched to the security tab
    1. Clicked Edit Permissions
    2. Removed the everyone permissions
    3. Added moderators Create / Reply / See
    4. Clicked “New Category”
  5. In a different browser, logged into try as a moderator.
  6. Navigated to the new “Mods Only” category.
  7. Successfully clicked on the “New Topic” button.

Besides not installing Discourse from scratch, do my steps differ from what you did in any way?

1 Like

He added moderators via the wizard?

3 Likes

Thanks Stephen, missed that.

Yeah, something is definitely off here. I re-ran the wizard on try and invited a moderator. Then I created a new category with the same steps as above. I then accepted the moderator invite, and I can’t even see the category in /categories. I’m definately a mod, though, as I can access the admin dashboard, admin user list, etc.

2 Likes

So the workaround (for now) would be to un-mod the person and re-mod them? Does that work?

1 Like

@nbianca can you investigate this.

4 Likes

Users are not in moderators / staff groups when invited from the wizard.

I submitted this PR to fix this:

https://github.com/discourse/discourse/pull/7530

9 Likes