Linking to a topic containing uploaded images looks awful

AI-generated summary

The discussion revolves around the appearance of links to topics containing multiple uploaded images in Discourse. Richie finds the current display of such links to be awful, suggesting two possible solutions: skipping or ignoring uploaded images for a cleaner preview, or thumbnailing images for a more meaningful display. codinghorror tests the issue but can’t reproduce it, while Canapin agrees that the current display is not ideal. Canapin also suggests replacing images with a shorter and more readable format, such as [image]. JammyDodger likes the idea of using tiny thumbnails, but notes that users often don’t give their images user-friendly names. Canapin agrees that most users don’t bother with descriptive image names, making it difficult to target ‘nonsense’ image names. codinghorror clarifies that the issue is with linking to a post from a different topic, and Richie confirms this.

Hi everyone,

When quoting / linking to a topic which contains a bunch of uploaded images I’ll be blunt here and say, it looks awful :see_no_evil:

(sorry, you know I love you guys!)

eg:

I’m not sure what the solution is but two suggestions spring to mind.

Suggestion one: A better user experience would be to either skip/ignore uploaded images completely, thereby providing a cleaner “preview”.

Suggestion two: Thumbnail the images so something more meaningful is displayed in the preview.

Open to more suggestions of course :blush:

5 Likes

OK let’s try this. Here are some images.


1 Like

I pressed the “full quote” button and got the above. I can’t repro @Richie?

test:

Do you think the images mentioned in the excerpt should be completely removed (would be a bit confusing in my example, with an “eg:” followed by… Nothing), like the excerpt shown outside Discourse? Here an example on Discord:

Or replaced by something shorter and more readable like [image]?

Do you think the behavior should be different in an excerpt that contains a lot of images (like your example), and one that doesn’t (like my example)?


But I like the idea of having tiny, inline thumbnails embedded in the excerpt with linking a topic on Discourse though., and like you, I don’t really like previews of messages with a bunch of [unclear_image_link] [unclear_image_link] [unclear_image_link] [unclear_image_link]
[unclear_image_link]
in the preview.

I name mine so they look okay/are useable in the Search and onebox links:

1 Like

A good habit I guess!
Most people don’t bother and just upload a bunch of pictures with non-user-friendly file names of their vacation through their smartphone though :smile:
They won’t even know how to change the display text.

This is very true. :slightly_smiling_face: It would be good if there was a way to target ‘nonsense’ image names from ‘intended’, as I find it quite a useful trick.

Oh wait, he’s referring to a link to the post from a different topic? My bad, I misread.

1 Like

Sorry Jeff @codinghorror I should have been clearer. Yes, exactly that :+1:t2:

1 Like