monumentex is building a community platform centered on emotional intelligence and relationships, using WordPress, WooCommerce, Discourse, Ultimate Member, and Paid Memberships Pro. The goal is to offer free public forums and paid private therapeutic sections. They seek confirmation that their architecture — assigning roles via Ultimate Member, syncing with Paid Memberships Pro, and mirroring permissions in Discourse via WP Discourse — is sound. They also ask if Discourse roles must be manually configured or sync automatically, and whether they’ve overlooked anything. monumentex references three prior threads for context and is open to hiring developers or designers.
omarfilip advises against using Ultimate Member and Paid Memberships Pro alongside WooCommerce, suggesting instead to use WC Subscriptions or WC Memberships for better integration and reliability. Alternatively, omarfilip recommends Discourse Subscriptions as a simpler, all-in-one solution — especially if membership benefits are forum-based — eliminating the need for WordPress membership plugins entirely.
monumentex acknowledges the cost concern (avoiding $200/yr for proprietary plugins) and expresses interest in exploring Discourse Subscriptions as a viable alternative.
Hi everyone, great to be a part of this community.
I’m developing a community around the topic of emotional intelligence and relationships. It’s a place where people can ask questions, vent frustrations, offer advice or just a listening ear. The base level of the forum will be free. A more intensive and therapeutic section will be private with paid subscription access.
I’d like to get some feedback on my implementation plan to make sure I’m on the right track. So far, I have prototyped this platform around these technologies:
Wordpress - CRM
WooCommerce - Vitamins, Health Products
Discourse - Forum
Ultimate Member - Account/Role Management
Paid Memberships Pro - Subscription Management
Am I correct in understanding that Roles should be set in Ultimate Member (Free Subscriber, Gold Member, Moderator, Author etc). Paid Membership Pro should fire hooks at Ultimate Member when someone upgrades accounts. Discourse can then mirror those groups and permissions through the WP Discourse plugin.
Do I have that right?
Do roles in Discourse need to be set up separately from roles in Ultimate Member? Does that copy over automatically?
Is there anything else that I need to consider in the development of this project?
I have read through these three threads. I suppose I’m just looking, not for implementation advice, but for confirmation that I have the core functionality laid out in the right way.
I’m also looking to hire a developer(s) and designer(s) to implement this project with me. Please don’t hesitate to give me a shout if you’re interested or you have an excellent recommendation on a graphic designer or a web developer you trust.
It is unnecessary to use all of these. Since you are going to be using WooCommerce anyway, a better approach would be to use WC Subscriptions and/or WC Memberships which integrate well with the WooCommerce core. Additional layers from PMPro and Ultimate Member will only complicate things and reduce reliability.
Alternatively, consider Discourse Subscriptions and use Discourse as the SSO provider. If the benefits of membership are access to specific areas of the forum, then this would probably be the best solution and you wouldn’t need WordPress membership management at all.