Minor Feature Request: Descriptions in List-Id headers

adamengst · 5월 3, 2018, 2:29오후

One of my readers pointed out that Discourse List-Id headers lack verbal descriptions, which would be helpful (in a small way). The short suggestion is to add descriptions in the form:

List-Id: Sitename | CategoryName <categoryslug.domain.name>

cheers… -Adam

PS: Here’s the message I got, so you can see where the guy is coming from.

Your mailing lists insert the List-Id tag into the mail header, which is nice and expected. However, they insert only the identifier without description. I get

List-ID: <article-comments.talk.tidbits.com>
List-ID: <tidbits-talk.talk.tidbits.com>
List-ID: <site-feedback.talk.tidbits.com>

Other lists include also a verbal description. For example, a few of my actual mailing lists:

List-Id: Macintosh Pascal Mailing List <mac-pascal.lists.sonic.net>
List-Id: How to use LiveCode <use-livecode.lists.runrev.com>
List-Id: MailMate Users <mailmate.lists.freron.com>
List-Id: Discussion for revIgniter <revigniter-livecodejournal.com>
List-ID: Eudora for the Mac <eudora-mac.cartel.listmoms.net>

I can set up my mail program to group the list posts by List-Id identifiers, but descriptions are much easier to see (I mean to click the correct mailing list), hence it would be great if you could have:

List-ID: TidBITS | Article Comments <article-comments.talk.tidbits.com>
List-ID: TidBITS | TidBITS Talk <tidbits-talk.talk.tidbits.com>
List-ID: TidBITS | Site Feedback <site-feedback.talk.tidbits.com>

zogstrip · 5월 3, 2018, 2:39오후

Looks like a good and easy idea

https://github.com/discourse/discourse/commit/7d223c0e5503b9b313b91ee588ec124531427644

LeoMcA · 5월 4, 2018, 10:40오전

A minor suggestion, wouldn’t #{parent_category_name} #{topic.category.name} make more sense here?

github.com/discourse/discourse

lib/email/sender.rb

7d223c0e5


      
            @message.header['References']  = [topic_message_id, referenced_post_message_ids].flatten.compact.uniq
          end
          
          # https://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc2919.txt
          if topic && topic.category && !topic.category.uncategorized?
            list_id = "#{SiteSetting.title} | #{topic.category.name} <#{topic.category.name.downcase.tr(' ', '-')}.#{host}>"
          
            # subcategory case
            if !topic.category.parent_category_id.nil?
              parent_category_name = Category.find_by(id: topic.category.parent_category_id).name
              list_id = "#{SiteSetting.title} | #{topic.category.name} #{parent_category_name} <#{topic.category.name.downcase.tr(' ', '-')}.#{parent_category_name.downcase.tr(' ', '-')}.#{host}>"
            end
          else
            list_id = "#{SiteSetting.title} <#{host}>"
          end
          
          # https://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc3834.txt
          @message.header['Precedence'] = 'list'
          @message.header['List-ID']    = list_id
          
          if topic

That way emails for (for instance) Development - Mozilla Discourse would be:

Mozilla | Add-ons Development

rather than:

Mozilla | Development Add-ons

zogstrip · 5월 4, 2018, 11:52오후

You’re right. I blindly copied the order of the List-Id…

https://github.com/discourse/discourse/commit/bae7203f4234e9ed23bc8e37213805f704ef0653

gde · 12월 11, 2021, 11:02오전

안녕하세요,

커뮤니티 사용자의 요청으로 이 기능 요청을 다시 올립니다.
사용자들은 그룹에서 메시지가 올 때 List-id에 더 많은 세부 정보가 포함되기를 원합니다.

'groups in subject’를 활성화했지만, 이는 사용자의 요구를 완전히 충족시키지 못하고 있습니다.

'groups in subject’가 true일 때 그룹 이름을 추가하는 것이 가능한가요?

글		댓글	조회수
Show categories in e-mail notifications Feature	50	9559	10월 13, 2014
Email: mail headers should have tags in them Feature	1	882	8월 16, 2014
Headers for email notifications so that Gmail users can filter on tags? Feature notifications , email	18	2112	1월 9, 2023
Emails are not threaded in Outlook 2013 Bug	30	15011	12월 11, 2014
Send category summaries to mailing lists Product Support	0	312	6월 11, 2021

Minor Feature Request: Descriptions in List-Id headers

Related topics