מלחין מובייל: מסך מלא קבוע

Summary

Mini experiment to keep mobile composer full-height, even when closing the keyboard.

Reason

  1. Avoid jumpy movements when interacting within composer, whenever the keyboard closes or opens

  2. Make re-reading your own post before submitting easier by using the fully available sceen

Screenshots

Notes

To see the forum while composing, you can still use the dedicated minimise button in the top right corner.

There may be potential differences in experiences between Hub/webapp, or the various browsers. Please report those to see if this is a viable change everywhere or not.

11 לייקים

I am a huge supporter of this change, it greatly improves my mobile experience

I can always minimize if I need to read something quickly

Quoting experience is great and seems to work fine on hub :+1:

3 לייקים

Hello :waving_hand: Yeah I like it too. Thanks :heart:

It would be nice if when I open the composer it would autofocus and open the keyboard on iOS as well.

The preview side is misaligned for me on iOS.

אולי זה רק אני, אבל אני מעדיף שהמלחין יהיה בגובה חצי כשהמקלדת סגורה, מכיוון שאני צריך לצטט דברים שונים מפוסט למעלה, אבל זה מקשה עליי - אני צריך לכווץ את כל המלחין במקום זאת.

3 לייקים

זה עובד מצוין, לא מצליח לשחזר שום באג. בנוסף, נראה טוב מאוד עבור iOS מכיוון שהקפיצה הייתה איטית שם, אני מניח.

On a smartphone, things look good to me. However, on tablets, I am less sure.
First, when I start a reply, the composer area is quite small (screenshot from a 12.9“ iPad below), definitely smaller than it needs to be.
But when I enter the text box and start typing, the composer goes fullscreen as for my iPhone, which is not really needed IMO (and there’s also no obvious means to resize it to half size - which is probably intended).

לייק 1

אני איתך, נייט, אבל אני אוהב להשתמש בשולחן העבודה לסוג כזה של אינטראקציה.

אני חושב שמסך מלא הוא חובה לחוויה נקייה במובייל; אפשר להקיש כדי לקרוא פוסטים קודמים.

2 לייקים

כן, חווית הטאבלט לוקה בחסר כרגע ויש לה עוד הרבה דברים ש"קורים" שאני צריך לבדוק כדי לייעל דברים. זה בהחלט דורש גישה שונה.

2 לייקים

האם תהיה אפשרות לשניהם? אני אוהב את המסך המלא לקריאה חוזרת, אבל אני גם אוהב את המסך החצוי להוספת ציטוטים והשוואת התשובה שלי לפוסט שאני מגיב אליו. כרגע, כשאני ממזער, הסמן ממוקם בסוף הטקסט של המלחין, והציטוט מופיע שם (כשאני רציתי לשים אותו באמצע הפוסט).

האם אוכל לקבל כפתור שמחליף בין מסך חצוי/מסך מלא (וגם ממזער)?

2 לייקים

No sorry, really not planning that. It’s already crowded enough as-is.

If we just manage to address this:

That should suffice to alleviate the desire of the half-composer, no?

לייק 1

Fixing that would be great. :raising_hands: :slight_smile:

But there’s also:

I like the half-composer for this too. I like the option of having both my bit and the thing I’m replying to next to each other without having to flick between screens. I think it helps me double-check what I’m saying is relevant and I’m replying to what was said and not just what I think someone said [1]


  1. results vary :slight_smile: ↩︎

4 לייקים

I swore i shared this on here already.

This is the same as my forum

Without composer clicked

After clicking compose button

האם ניתן להשתמש בו בפורום דיסקרוס מותקן כעת?

לייק 1

Not yet! It’s still experimental for now, but I’m planning on moving in into core very soon and then it will be available everywhere.

לייק 1

תודה, מחכה בקוצר רוח לזה, ניסיתי במטא וזה עובד מצוין גם באפליקציית ווב וגם בספארי.

לייק 1

Edit: Just realized that this is by design and, according to the quote below, “experimental”.

In that case, it would have been a more graceful solution to make it opt-in only via site settings, just like any other experimental feature, and not force it upon all users.

I wish someone could come up with a workaround plugin or a hotfix to bring back the split-view composer.

3 לייקים

I didn’t realize this change was intentional, but it makes the experience on mobile significantly worse for me. Why does the composer need to be full screen to review what you wrote? There’s already a preview button for that which does the same thing but better. Now it’s much harder to check what I wrote against the post(s) I’m replying to since I can only see my text (full screen composer) or their text (minimize the composer), never both at the same time.

3 לייקים

I experimented a bit with building a Theme component that basically renders the cooked post I am replying to, right above the composer. But that didn’t really cover the use case when I want to quote text snippets from multiple posts in a subsequent manner.

I would rather have a non-fullscreen adjustable composer text area which then expands with each consequent line break.

When replying, opening an empty composer in full height is definitely not the best use of the very limited space on a smartphone. See screenshot below and the red marking.