Move only part of a reply (and some other entire replies) to a new topic

Not sure if there might be a lof of need for such a feature.

Quite often, in our forum people reply to a previous message in a topic and raise a new topic in the next paragraph of the same reply.

Actually, that’s us who teach users not to write multiple replies but rather use “quote reply” and put everything in a single reply.

Now, if I want to keep one piece of the message in its topic and move another piece of the message (and some of the following replies) in a separate topic, how do I do it - is it possible and if not, is it a planned feature?

1개의 좋아요

Not possible, nor planned to allow splitting of a paragraph from a post. Splits are granular at the post level.

1개의 좋아요

Yes, I see what you mean, but I agree with @codinghorror that splitting posts is a no go. But let’s look at this more closely: I’d say raising a new topic in a reply isn’t a problem per se. The problem starts when someone replies to that new topic within the old topic. (And I don’t really blame inexperienced users for doing this, as it requires quite some discipline to realize that you need to reply-as-new-topic to one part of the post but can reply-within-topic to another part of the post.)

So if we look at a situation where someone replies to a new topic within the old topic, I think a feasible solution would be to copy to new topic.

Now, it does get a bit more complicated because only the post that introduced the new topic would have to be copied while the replies would need to be moved (also because copying should be kept to an absolute minimum).

If the reply not only replies to the off topic part of the post but also also to the on-topic part, I think we just gotta leave the “mess” as it is and intervene with a reply, asking to please continue the off topic conversation elsewhere.

3개의 좋아요

여기서 답변들이 이렇게 극명하게 대립하는 것이 흥미롭네요. Moving only part of a post - #2 by codinghorror 의 이전 글들은 훨씬 더 개방적이었다는 점을 고려하면요.

Splitting a message in 2 - #2 by omarfilip 에 임시 해결책이 있다는 것을 발견했습니다.

이것은 분명히 복잡한 문제이지만, 제 생각에는 이 아이디어에 상당한 가치가 있습니다.

게시글의 일부를 이동하면 토픽 분할 프로세스에 너무 많은 복잡성이 추가된다는 데 동의합니다.

프로세스는 같은 사용자가 소유한 더 작은 게시글로 게시글을 분할하는 것이어야 합니다(예: Splitting a message in 2 참조). 그런 다음 필요에 따라 분할된 게시글을 다른 토픽으로 이동하면 됩니다.