On Meta, user jesselperry reports a bug where muting a topic in the plugin category still results in notifications, despite the topic not appearing in the category feed. codinghorror suggests checking if the topic was recategorized or if there’s a subcategory vs. category issue. sam investigates and confirms the topic is muted, but suspects the issue stems from notifications being queued before the mute action. sam notes a confusing help text related to notifications and plans to fix it, while also acknowledging the bug persists. Kosh links a related issue where muted topics still appear in the window tab, highlighting ongoing notification display problems.
I just noticed on Meta a bug where muting a topic is still sending me notifications about the topic. Upon looking into this specific case, it’s even stranger.
Here’s the scenario:
I am “Watching” the plugin category. I started getting email notifications about this topic: Discourse Topic Voting
I don’t want to receive notifications on this topic, so I muted it.