Need log the who downloaded attachments

סיכום מבוסס בינה מלאכותית

The discussion revolves around the need to log which users download attachments on a Discourse site. appcomq initially notes the lack of such tracking and expresses concern over large nginx logs with 40,000 users. codinghorror suggests checking nginx logs, but appcomq finds them unwieldy. appcomq shares a screenshot showing only download counters exist, and asks if logging user downloads is technically feasible. They later reference the outdated df-restricted-files plugin, incompatible with Discourse 1.8. dax recommends the Data Explorer plugin to query download data, while tophee cautions that attachments are publicly accessible via direct links. appcomq proposes modifying a script to log user access to .zip/.rar files with usernames. AndyBr questions if a newer restricted files plugin exists. pfaffman points to a secure media uploads topic, which AndyBr finds intimidating and notes they don’t use S3. pfaffman clarifies Data Explorer can track post views but not downloads, and offers paid help to restrict uploads to logged-in users. AndyBr declines due to budget constraints. The core need remains: tracking downloaders and optionally restricting access — both currently unsupported out-of-the-box.

:face_with_thermometer:

My site canot know who downloaded attachments.

Check your nginx logs for that information.

nginx logs too big data.

now have 40,000 users. :face_with_thermometer:

Now only have counter, I wanto logs who user download. can it be technically possible?

I find this GitHub - discourse-pro/df-restricted-files: The «Restricted Files» plugin for Discourse · GitHub

but canot use 1.8

You can install Data explorer plugin and write an SQL query for that (or ask here if someone can write a query for you (Superseded) What cool data explorer queries have you come up with?)

לייק 1

Note that attachments can be downloaded by anyone who has the link.

לייק 1

I have a idea, use

script/nginx_analyze.rb

can help me add the code ? Output all zip and rar url User access Filename + username.

So I know who downloaded it.

Is there a new restricted files plugin? Seems the one you linked to is quite old and may not be compatible with the latest version of discourse?

See https://meta.discourse.org/t/secure-media-uploads/meta/140017, perhaps?

Woa! Looks scary.
Also, Not using s3 (which I assume means Amazon)?
Thanks though.
Just want to get a list of people who’ve downloaded files, and if i could protect those files to only authorized users that would be a bonus!

I think you could get a list of who saw those posts with data explorer. I don’t know that you can tell who downloaded them.

If you have a budget I might help with limiting access to uploads to users who are logged in.

לייק 1

Thank you.
Unfortunately I have no budget for any customization at this time.

לייק 1