通知所有群组管理员处理加入请求

[neemiasvf (Neemias Freitas)]

Hi there!

I’m not sure if this is a bug or not, but I’ve been doing some research for quite a while now and didn’t find anything related to my problem, so here it goes:

In my Discourse instance, I have a closed group where people can request to join. When a request is made, all group owners should be notified and included in the personal message, right? Wrong. There wasn’t a single request where all group owners were notified; it was always some of the owners, apparently picked randomly. And this keeps happening every time and it’s been happening for a long time, even with all the updates and stuff. So I beg to ask: is this a bug? Or is Discourse actually programmed to notify only some of the group owners and not all of them?

Some relevant information:

• the given group currently has 10 group owners;
• some of the group owners are moderators and others are administrators, but all of them are staff members.

Could someone shed some light on this?
Perhaps I’m doing something wrong or didn’t configure a setting correctly…

[neemiasvf (Neemias Freitas)]

Alright, I just found this: FIX: Only send membership request to the last 5 active group owners. · discourse/discourse@ad4a96d · GitHub

Could we make this customisable?

I’m basically bringing up this topic again:

Improving the Groups page for 1.7

One of the last big things on the 1.7 release list is to improve the groups page. @tgxworld will be working on this in December, so I wanted to gather feedback and make sure we didn’t miss anything. Here’s what I remember about it so far: general cleanup of the groups page design, not a radical redesign but make it more… presentable. show the group avatar (that @neil already worked on) on the group page prominently, since that is how the group is iden…

Specially the comments on the limit of 5 members:

Improving the Groups page for 1.7

Not sure we need any cap since only owners are specified in the to: line. I guess last 5 active owners adds a sanity limit, but do people generally have more than 5 owners. Also, perhaps all owners should get the PM. The larger issue IMO in the @mention in the body of the owner notification email. A workaround is here. This @mention issue and who gets notified isn’t really related to this group feature, but the specific PM generated could use a fix.

[Hanon_Ondricek]

有没有什么策略可以知道何时存在长期未处理的群组加入请求？我们的论坛上有几个群组，仅在一年中的特定时间段流量较大，如果有人在非高峰时段申请加入，请求往往会被搁置数天甚至数周。由于大约有十六个群组，每天逐个点击每个群组并检查请求标签确实有些繁琐。

我们的群组所有者在非赛季期间通常并不经常参与论坛活动，但作为版主和管理员，我每天都会登录论坛。最好的办法是不是让自己成为所有群组的群组所有者之一，以便收到加入请求的通知？

[codinghorror (Jeff Atwood)]

@Hanon_Ondricek

最好的方法是不是让我成为每个群组的群主之一，这样我就能收到请求通知？

@nbianca，对此有什么想法吗？有哪些可能的建议？

[nbianca (Bianca)]

我这里有几个想法，但我最喜欢的是将当前的群组页面修改为同时显示成员申请的数量。这应该是一个简单的改动，能够提供所有活跃申请的概览。

我喜欢第三个设计稿（见第4个群组），但也欢迎其他建议。

另一个我能想到的方案是添加一个新页面（或者放在群组列表底部，或者作为群组页面的一个标签页），列出所有活跃的成员申请，但我认为这样会让事情变得比必要的更复杂。