Continuing the discussion from a topic in the Lounge:
Pulling this out to a public topic for follow-up.
The discussion revolves around changing the icons for âclosed topicâ and âsecure categoryâ in Discourse to avoid confusion between the two concepts. Users debate the effectiveness of various icons, including a lock, a speech bubble with a slash, and a stop sign, with concerns about clarity, size, and potential misinterpretation. Some argue that the current lock icon is misleading due to its association with security, while others prefer maintaining it for familiarity. The conversation highlights the difficulty in finding a universally clear icon, with some suggesting that âclosedâ topics should be represented by a stop sign to indicate no further replies, while others advocate for reverting to the original lock icon. The thread includes mockups and user feedback on different designs, ultimately reflecting a broader debate on iconography and user experience in software design.
Continuing the discussion from a topic in the Lounge:
Pulling this out to a public topic for follow-up.
Definitely please take this into account. I have already had to do this with a theme component so I cannot confuse them.
fa-user-lock is a good icon you could use?
Example below:
I agree on that. One of my clients made me hide the padlock icon on âprivateâ categories because it was confusing.
On an instance with mostly private categories, it can also be an eyesore. I removed all the padlocks from the private categories and instead placed an âeyeâ icon in front of the few public categories we have.
What would these symbols be? As I recall, I donât think there are any clearly better alternatives from the last time this bike shed was painted @stephen âŠ
Iâve used the eye symbol in the past, and experimented with the open lock, but thereâs nothing wrong with just removing the icon all together. Itâs down to the community owners to emphasize the purpose and audience for each category, a padlock icon doesnât achieve that really, it just indicates that the everyone group isnât present on the category.
Many systems with ACLs donât indicate the ACL visually on the object. File sharing services will indicate that an object is shared, but not the level of permissions associated. If I have access to a folder over a network share then I can see it, if I donât have browse rights it just doesnât appear. Even Exchange relies/relied on visibility to indicate whether the user has access.
Is the concern that a user wonât realise the category has a limited number of watchers? In that sense I would be more worried about indicating which categories have a broader or public audience than less.
Category Icons component uses fa-key and it even offers to replace padlock with key for private categories (and retains padlock for closed ones), but itâs not consistent as of yet.
fa-user-lock for private categories
fa-lock for closed topics
This is one thing I customized at my Discourse instance in my previous job.
A closed topic is closed for everyone, and no-one has access to it, so the icon keeps being
, aka Lock Filled Icon (Classic Solid) â Free SVG Download | Font Awesome
A secure category is closed for other people, but open for you, so the icon was
, aka Lock Open Filled Icon (Classic Solid) â Free SVG Download | Font Awesome
If we can decide on the bikeshed color in a way that doesnât go on forever, Iâm fine with the change ![]()
Can we just confirm the intent of the symbol?
It is just âlacks the everyone permissionâ? That seems to be the only time where it appears. Even categories secured to TL0 show a padlock.
Correct. It indicates that not everyone may be able to see it.
It still appears on login required forums (where the everyone permission is irrelevant) even if TL0 can see.
Ok and if weâre using categories how regularly is that a factor?
Is it there still because thatâs how itâs always been? Does it influence posting?
Iâm just being clear it isnât impacted by other site settings. As in on a login required forum, even if âall usersâ can see a topic, based on TL0 permissions, the padlock still appears due to the lack of the specific everyone permission.
Why? What is the difference between a padlock and a padlock with a user next to it? I donât think this will aid comprehension at all..
The only point of doing this is making it so people donât mistake a topic in a secure category as being a closed topic. The icons are right next to each other! Iâve had far too many double takes slowing me down while reading Meta recently.
Anything that changes the silhouette / visual weight / âvisual hashâ, if you will, of the icon is acceptable to me (so
is not OK, still very close to a lock).
If we are painting bikesheds here⊠I would like an opinion from @Johani and @awesomerobot
Also ⊠my 2 cents, no eye being slashed by a knife please ⊠that is not on the table.