The discussion revolves around implementing “pull to refresh” functionality in Discourse for mobile devices, particularly on iOS. Terrapop suggests adding this feature, commonly seen in apps like Twitter, to improve user experience, especially on iOS where the current update banner can be hard to reach with one hand. Falco notes that Chrome on Android already supports this, while Stephen explains that the dynamic update panel already works in Chrome on iOS, though not in Safari or the Discourse app. codinghorror argues the current system is sufficient. Terrapop counters that iOS has a significant market share and the banner’s reachability is an issue, especially without reachability mode enabled. Stephen clarifies that reachability makes the banner accessible and that the feature has been in use for years without widespread complaints. Terrapop expresses surprise at the reachability feature and suggests a custom implementation using a lightweight library, which they have successfully tested 16.
It would be nice if @team could think about adding “pull to refresh” functionality for mobile as you know from other social media apps like Twitter etc (at least for “latest” sections, possibly others make sense, too).
It works in Chrome in iOS too, just not in Safari or the Discourse Hub app.
The only place where this would be remotely useful is topic lists, but even then the user is already made aware of updates and can refresh from that update prompt.
Don’t know what to see in the video… the banner can’t be reached from the easy zone on iOS, it’s not in the lower-left corner. Re market shares, that’s even worse then for communities in Europe/US.
So, I’m still advocating for a proprietary pull-to-refresh solution for Discourse to have the same UX experience on mobile across devices. That’s why most other apps do it.
Fair enough, that is your personal opinion. I have a different one.
For those interested to have a better user experience for iOS users: It is possible to build a simple component for the mobile view with the lightweight pull2refresh library (7kb minified). We did it and it works now as expected on all mobile devices without the need for 2 clicks required on iOS with the hidden feature enabled.