请求:系统编辑帖子时不应显示“已编辑”图标

We have the “downloaded local copies of images” setting enabled, and just realized that in some cases this causes the “edited” (pencil) icon to display at the top of the post.

In our experience the “edited” icon is useful for seeing at a glance when a user has actually changed the substance of a post.

For behind the scenes housekeeping stuff like making image URLs local, invisible to most users, I think this indicator should be suppressed. Maybe some cases where a system edit should be visible, but for this local image thing in particular, or similar invisible edits, seems ideal to not display it as “edited”.

5 个赞

Search settings for " disable system edit notifications"

4 个赞

Ah thanks Jay. Just checked and we actually do have that setting enabled already!

Maybe that setting isn’t being respected for showing the edit icon as well (though I think it should be). Example here, shows the edited / pencil icon for system edit:

1 个赞

No edit icon showing here. Maybe a screenshot would. :wink:

Huh weird I see it on both desktop and mobile, logged in or anon. Here are screenshots from mobile.

1 个赞

iPad Chrome I could not only see the pencil icon, I also could see the revision.

Troy has a shield. Can you see a different example of a member not in that group?

2 个赞

Sorry, I was looking at the Oneboxed link here. When I went to your site I did see the revision. The videos themselves were highlighted to show something was changed in the data by the system. All text is identical - no changes. The system did something when downloading the video, but no edit pencil should be showing.
And yes, Troy has a shield after his name.

1 个赞

想跟进一下,因为这仍然是一个小烦恼。系统编辑显然不应显示编辑指示器(铅笔图标)。特别是在启用了“禁用系统编辑通知”的情况下,但也许即使不考虑该设置,也应作为一般情况处理。

当实际上没有任何内容更改,仅仅是后台 URL 重写时,看到那个橙色的“已编辑”图标会让人感到突兀。

(另外,不确定如何查看这种情况发生的频率,因为这些系统编辑似乎不会在“员工操作”>“帖子编辑”日志中添加记录,除非我漏掉了什么!)

Discourse 团队,有什么想法吗?你们支持这里建议的更改吗?

3 个赞

但这确实属于内容变更。

1 个赞

我想你明白我的意思!是的,原始帖子的字面差异确实发生了变化。不,最终显示的帖子内容没有任何变化。

如果某项改动本质上不可见,那么特意指出它并无益处。这甚至不是图片本身的变化,仅仅是“这张图片现在托管在另一个地方”——对任何读者来说都是毫无意义的变动,只会增加困惑。

4 个赞

我也这么认为!我不喜欢被那个略带焦虑感的橙色铅笔图标吸引过去,结果只看到这些:

image

image

依我看,我们根本不应该显示铅笔图标,而是将其作为内部维护工作处理。如果用户恰好关心 URL,他们自然会了解到 Discourse 会抓取热链接的图片。如果这种改动太大,我们至少应该将这些图标的默认颜色从橙色改为灰色,但这可能不容易实现,因为颜色很可能是根据编辑时间远近来决定的:thinking:

image

3 个赞

我以为有个系统设置可以那样做,不过我在手机上找不到。

2 个赞

我知道这个设置,但即使已启用,我还是收到了该通知:

image

3 个赞

这可能与 @sam 最近的编辑通知修复有关?

2 个赞

今天晚些时候会看一下

3 个赞

等等,初衷从来就不是要禁用修订,该设置 100% 是关于禁用通知的,具体如下:

这已经生效了,我在本地测试过:

如果我们想扩展这个站点设置,我想我们可以添加:

hide system edit revisions:隐藏系统在下载热链接图片时创建的修订。

由你决定,@codinghorror,如果你想对此进行调整的话。但就目前而言,铅笔图标是 100% 按设计实现的,被抑制的是用户收到的关于修订的通知。

6 个赞

哦不,我想说的是我不喜欢帖子上的橙色编辑修订标记。我可以确认我没有收到通知,所以这方面运行符合预期——为造成的混淆致歉!

上方的请求 以及 其上方的请求 是针对你提到的“隐藏系统编辑修订”行为,它们与通知无关。

6 个赞