이메일 답장에서 인용 블록이 사라짐

기여 버그
1

콘텐츠가 많은 게시물을 생각해 보세요. 특정 부분에 이메일로 답장하려면, 인용된 콘텐츠를 해당 부분 단락만 남기고 잘라낸 뒤 답장을 추가합니다.

:bug: 이 특정 경우, Discourse는 인용된 콘텐츠를 제거하고 사용자 자신의 텍스트만 표시합니다… 이렇게 인용된 콘텐츠를 자르는 이유는 원래 게시물에서 매우 구체적인 부분에 답하고 있음을 명확히 하려는 것이므로, 중요한 컨텍스트 정보가 손실됩니다.

누가 무심코 전체 이메일을 인용하여 답장을 추가할 때 불필요한 요소를 제거하려는 목표는 이해합니다. 인용된 콘텐츠의 길이를 계산하여 10줄 또는 800자 이하라면 유지하도록 제안합니다. 아니면 현재 답장이 참조하는 원래 게시물의 길이를 계산하여 인용문이 그 원래 게시물 길이의 50% 미만이라면 유지하도록 하는 것도 방법입니다.

동작하는 경우와 작동하지 않는 경우의 상세한 샘플

여러 블록의 인용된 콘텐츠가 있는 경우, 모든 인용문이 올바르게 유지됩니다:

On Wed, 18 Mar 2020, Jonathan Carter via Debian Discourse wrote:
> Personally, when it comes to web-based forums, I tend to use them for a
> while and then only remember I have an account on them a few years
> later. 

I'm replying right now in my mail reader. You will always find limitations
in the email integration but IMO it works well enough to be usable. And
if we ever switch, I'm pretty sure that someone annoyed enough by the lack
of some feature will find a way to implement it. It's free software after
all.

> IMHO only using the e-mail interface would kind of defeat the purpose
> (you might as well use a mailing list then) since all the nice features
> that's available are exposed in the web interface.

I would expect most people to not use the email interface in general but
its existence is a requirement IMO to not segregate a part of our
community which is reluctant to work with anything else.

하지만 단일 블록인 경우, 인용문이 삭제됩니다:

On Wed, 18 Mar 2020, Kyle Robbertze via Debian Discourse wrote:
> Often I wish to reply to a certain piece of a comment and maintain the
> context I am replying to. How do I do that when replying to emails
> generated by Discourse? So far I have found that just leaving the
> context in, like I would in email, results in it being stripped out.

I have not had this problem so far. It has been working fine for me.
Here's for example how my current reply looks like when sent via mutt:
https://paste.debian.net/1135454/

이러한 동작은 여기서 Discourse를 시험해 보고 있는 몇몇 Debian 개발자들을 놀라게 했습니다:
https://discourse.debian.net/t/how-to-quote-in-email-replies/81

그리고 여기:
https://discourse.debian.net/t/dear-dpl-candidates-what-are-your-thoughts-on-discourse/75/7?u=buxy

2개의 좋아요
2

Any thoughts here @gerhard?

3

I may be reading it wrong, but I suspect:

is be responsible here.

I don’t think that email_reply_trimmer knows about what it’s replying to, as it’s called from discourse/lib/email/receiver.rb.

3개의 좋아요
4

That’s probably it. email_reply_trimmer is quite dumb and doesn’t know anything about previous messages.

Feel free to send a PR that makes this work for your use case. But I fear that it will be hard to fix without some larger changes… Anyway, I’m bookmarking this topic to have another look if/when we get a chance to refactor the reply trimming.

4개의 좋아요
5

I am not sure about this perhaps this is the remove full quote site setting, which “Automatically remove full quotes on direct replies.”

Is this incoming email specific or just general forum usage? In the topic you linked I did not see any email replies so I am very much guessing you simply want to disable that site setting.

2개의 좋아요
6

Hi,

remove full quote is indeed set.

This appears to coming from email replies specifically - on that page there’s a number of replies, messages 1,2,5,6,9,10 and 13 are all replies by email.

7

I recommend disabling that site setting on the Debian instance

8

Thanks @sam, done so. I suspect the reply trimmer should probably be made a bit smarter, but for the moment this should be fine for our use :slight_smile:

1개의 좋아요
9

이 문제는 수정되었습니다. FIX: preserve inline replies and image lines when trimming emails - Pull Request #25 - discourse/email_reply_trimmer - GitHub 를 확인해 주세요.

1개의 좋아요