SMS secondary verification

AI-generated summary

In a discussion titled ā€œSMS secondary verificationā€ under the Marketplace category, aksoforever seeks help developing a plugin for SMS-based two-factor authentication (2FA) in Discourse, despite concerns raised by seanblue and Remah about SMS’s security vulnerabilities, citing articles and recommending alternatives like Google Authenticator. aksoforever acknowledges the security concerns but insists SMS is preferred in China for its simplicity and widespread use, even among major apps. They request pricing for developing such a plugin. pfaffman questions whether aksoforever has an SMS provider with a documented API, capable of sending messages to Chinese numbers (even from outside China), and suggests a budget of $1000–$5000. aksoforever confirms they can use international providers like Twilio or Aliyun (linking to Aliyun’s SMS documentation), and asks for details on collaboration. The thread highlights the tension between user preference for familiar, convenient SMS 2FA and security best practices, while focusing on practical implementation hurdles and cost.

Dear

I want to make a plugin for sms authentication login

After user login with password requires SMS secondary verification

Who can help me to do this, please give me a quote.
Thank you very much!!!

Using SMS for two factor authentication isn’t particularly secure. You might want to consider a different approach.

4 Likes

Why?

What would you recommend?

1 Like

For example: This is why you shouldn’t use texts for two-factor authentication | The Verge

I tend to use Google Authenticator, but there are plenty of options out there.


Is two factor authentication not already an option on Discourse though? It seems likely it is.
EDIT: I see there’s some option for it in user settings.

2 Likes

Check out the external links in these two topics for more info on the lack of security using SMS:

2 Likes

@seanblue @Remah Dear All
Thanks for your reminder,
I know the discourse suggest more secure secondary verification:like Google Authenticator

but we like it becouse it sample, maybe someday we use the 2FA app like Google Authenticator,
I’m from china, in our country, Almost all apps, including large companies, use SMS authentication.
so, i want to know how much should i pay to achieve the sms verification.

2 Likes

Anyone who can help me to do this plugin,
Please…let me know the price.

1 Like

Have you a means of sending text messages in China? You already have an account to send texts and can provide credentials for sending texts to develop the plugin? Do they have an API that’s well documented? Can that text provider send texts outside of China if the developer isn’t in China?

You haven’t mentioned a budget, which often means that the person asking doesn’t have a sufficient budget. I’m not sure just how hard it’ll be. Do you have all of the above and $1000 to $5000?

1 Like

thanks, we can use the SMS provider like Twilio, or other not chinese prover.
just make sure the chinese phone number can recieve the verification code,
like my phone can recieve the google verification code for login gmail.
can you give me more detail about how we can cooperation.

1 Like

This is the Aliyun SMS documentation.
It is in Chinese.

1 Like

This topic was automatically closed 30 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.