"Take Action" button doesn't really indicate what it does

AI-generated summary

Users are discussing the ambiguity of the “Take Action” button on their forum. notriddle shared an experience where another moderator was unsure of the button’s function, which is to hide individual posts. They suggest changing the label to something more descriptive, such as “Hide post”, and replacing the thumbs-up icon with a more informative one.

Jagster agrees that the current label is unclear and proposes renaming the button to “Hide post”. They mention that this is a UX issue rather than a bug.

JammyDodger provides a temporary solution by explaining how to customize the button’s text through the site’s settings. They also invite users to share their suggestions for a more intuitive description.

notriddle asks if it’s possible to change the icon as well, to which JammyDodger responds that it may be achievable through a custom theme component, providing a link to a relevant discussion on the topic.

After I used this button, another mod on the same forum asked how to hide individual posts. I pointed out where it was, but they still didn’t get it.

I wound up having to tell them to use the button that “weirdly enough, has a :+1: icon” to hide the individual post. It doesn’t say, anywhere, what this actually does.

Could this label be made a bit more informative, like having it say somewhere that it hides the post, or being marked with an icon more informative than the thumbs-up?

3 Likes

I agree. Those texts are descriptions for a dev/coder and admin how buttons are working, not for an user to tell what buttons do.

I don’t use that menu like ever, so I don’t know what Take action does… but if it just hides a post could it be something as Hide post?

Other two options don’t need anykind descriptions. Texts are there just making layout more uniform :wink:

But my bureaucratic side whispers that is not bug, but UX question.

You can change the text of that button for your site by editing the js.flagging.take_action and js.flagging.take_action_options.default.details fields in /admin/customize/site_texts/

Though we’re always open to making changes to descriptions if people think they could be more intuitive. :+1: If you land on a good one for your site could you share it here and we can see if it would work for everybody?

Is there a way to change the icon, too?

I believe it may be possible using a custom theme component: