This topic is clearly important to you – you've posted more than 25% of the replies here

Contribute UX
1

Can you please help me understand this notification my readers are receiving?

We have a thread that’s posted to daily. It could be a weekly thread, I suppose.

But I’ve posted in it let’s say 14 times, another person 16 times, but one person that posted to it less than the top thread posters has received a notification to let others join the conversation. Are you sure you’re providing adequate time for other people to share their points of view, too? LOL I shouldn’t laugh, but that’s hilarious to me and not quite as funny for the person who received it.

I’ve never seen this myself, so didn’t even realize it existed. I get notices that I should combine my posts instead of making new posts in a thread a lot. I just ignore them. Because yeah, I do that and it’s not going to change. LOL I post the way I think. It’s often rapid and then I edit and refine if needed, sometimes not. Strong personality and all. I also ramble. Perhaps I’ll get a notification that says hey get to the point!

Are these types of notifications beneficial to others? I’d like a show of hands, please if you like this!
I get it. Really I see the intention. I just lean toward not agreeing with it.

I’d like you to consider what I’ve experienced so far.

Upon starting my community, my brand new members were told to come back later, they had posted too many times that day. LOL I believe I changed the default settings on that, so my goof and oversight. I can’t remember. It’s been months.

Then this? Am I again missing a setting?

Let’s just say someone’s personality shines through with these notifications and it’s not mine. Couldn’t resist !

So where do I fix this? And wouldn’t it be nice if I could figure out how to see all of these notifications that I might personally never see and shut them off entirely.

I’ve only had one coffee today, so hopefully I overlooked a setting…err, again.

2개의 좋아요
2

To edit those thresholds, they are under Admin → Settings → Other.

To disable them entirely, set sequential replies threshold and dominating topic minimum percent to be something like 1000.

5개의 좋아요
3

Thank you! I appreciate it. I was pretty certain I was missing settings because by default, this is just crazy, imo! I do wish I could check a box on or off for things versus putting in some high number, though. But all is great in the world again and I’m always happy with the quick and helpful responses here.

4

Glad it helped. I get why it’s there, but I am also not much of a fan of that particular JIT warning myself. Having the software suggest that a user shush on a particularly heavy-hitting subject was not a good experience for them. I disabled it right away when I got that feedback.

2개의 좋아요
5

A member was affected enough to comment on this warning today.

Whilst I agree with this type of warning in principle and want to avoid forum domination I think the logic could be finessed to take into account the number of likes received by the poster on the current thread. If the user has an above-average number of likes they should be able to post without encountering the warning.

1개의 좋아요
6

The general idea is that a conversation dominated by one person isn’t much of an actual conversation – conversations are better when people pause, reflect, and listen to others regularly.

4개의 좋아요
7

Agree with you on forum domination, @codinghorror. In general the warning is totally appropriate.

However, I’d hate some of our extra-knowledgeable members to get told off for posting more than others.

On the topic I mentioned, a handful of members had attended an important meeting IRL and the rest of the forum was waiting eagerly for their reports. But one of them got the warning and was put off from reporting back to us all.

8

Feel free to adjust your site settings if you feel the setting does not apply to your situation.

9

@ChrisBeach On my forum, it happened on a gratitude thread. Nothing like sharing what you’re thankful for and getting a notification to shut-up. LOL She took it well, but I didn’t understand why two others (myself included), didn’t receive a notification and had dominated the conversation more. Maybe I just ignored it. I don’t recall ever seeing it and believe me, I am a conversation hog on my own forum. I am constantly engaging in and encouraging more conversations even in single threads.

@codinghorror I do see and understand the intent. I’d like to be able to shut some of these notices off, but I am fine with simply raising the threshold. Look! What notice? I changed the setting and it won’t happen again. :slight_smile: When I posted, I wasn’t sure what I could do and where to find how to change it. I simply didn’t look well enough. I did wonder if people liked the notifications, though and whether they would like to be able to turn some or all of them off or edit the wording.

10

I find it to be a helpful reminder, because I am a man, and men tend to dominate discussions (more-or-less) accidentally.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-2205502/The-great-gender-debate-Men-dominate-75-conversation-conference-meetings-study-suggests.html

On technical debugging topics where there’s not really a discussion per se, it is not directly applicable, so I just ignore it in those cases.

2개의 좋아요
11

You do know I’m laughing, right? I’m laughing alone, probably. I do always like to see the thinking behind decisions and how those decisions are received, I appreciate your perspective.

6개의 좋아요
13

안녕하세요, 이 메시지를 끄는 방법을 찾다가 이 스레드를 발견했는데, 제 질문에 대부분 답변이 되어 있지만 후속 질문이 있습니다: - 비율을 100%로 설정하면, 이 자동 응답이 작동하기 전에 스레드에 몇 개의 게시글이 있어야 하나요?

예를 들어, 사용자가 새로운 스레드를 시작한 후 누락한 추가 정보를 보충하거나 자신의 스레드를 상단으로 올리기 위해 스스로에게 답글을 남기는 경우가 있습니다. 이 경우 게시글은 단 2개이지만, 모두 한 사람으로부터 온 것이므로 100%에 해당합니다.

사라의 의견에 동의합니다. 이러한 유형의 설정에 대해 켜기/끄기 옵션이 제공되는 것이 더 바람직합니다! 저는 애도 지원 사이트를 운영 중이므로 사람들이 얼마나 자주 게시글을 작성하는지 감시하는 것은 적절하지 않습니다. 따라서 이러한 자동 메시지가 제 눈앞을 스쳐 지나가지 않도록 확인하고 있습니다.

4개의 좋아요
15

이러한 JIT 관리자 설정이 '기타’에 숨겨져 있는 것보다, 사용자가 더 쉽게 찾을 수 있도록 별도의 탭으로 묶어두는 것이 좋다고 생각합니다. 또한, 원할 경우 비활성화하기가 더 편리하도록 사용자 친화적으로 개선할 필요가 있다고 판단하여 Contribute > UX 채널로 이 내용을 옮겼습니다.

이름 설명 기본값
educate until posts 사용자가 첫 (n)개의 새 게시글을 입력하기 시작할 때, 작성기에 신규 사용자 교육 팝업 패널을 표시합니다. 2
sequential replies threshold 토픽 내에서 연속으로 게시글을 작성한 후 연속 답변이 많다는 알림을 받기까지 필요한 게시글 수. 2
get a room threshold 같은 토픽에서 같은 사람에게 게시글을 작성한 후 경고가 표시되기까지 필요한 게시글 수. 3
dont feed the trolls threshold 다른 사용자로부터 플래그를 받은 후 경고가 표시되기까지 필요한 플래그 수. 2
dominating topic minimum percent 토픽 내에서 과도하게 지배하고 있다는 알림이 표시되기까지 사용자가 작성해야 하는 게시글 비율. 40
disable avatar education message 아바타 변경 관련 교육 메시지를 비활성화합니다. false
1개의 좋아요