Topic-activiteitsindicator (blauwe stip) te groot op sommige Android-apparaten

AI-generated summary

Users reported that the topic activity indicator (blue dot) in Discourse appears excessively large on some Android devices, particularly Samsung phones, causing distraction. itsbhanusharma first highlighted the issue, noting it occurs on Android 10 with Chrome and is specific to mobile. Mevo questioned if it was theme-related, but itsbhanusharma confirmed it occurs in the default Light theme, even on Meta. codinghorror asked for reproducibility, and dax initially couldn’t reproduce it on Chrome 85 and Android 10 with the Light theme. ondrej noted it had occurred on a tablet but not recently. itsbhanusharma found the issue consistent on Samsung devices but not on Xiaomi/Poco phones, suggesting a Samsung-specific issue. Canapin confirmed the problem on a Galaxy S5 with Android 8 and Chrome 85. dax later observed the issue on Firefox with a Huawei device, indicating it’s not limited to Samsung. itsbhanusharma clarified that Samsung was the most consistent repro. Finally, Johani confirmed the issue was fixed by a commit and thanked itsbhanusharma for reporting it.

I really don’t know if it was done on purpose but this has become an annoying distraction. Is there a way to make it behave like it used to? The small blue dot worked just fine.

EDIT: seems like it is only related to mobile, Reproduced on two android devices with latest chrome on android 10.

4 likes

Can’t this be related to the theme you’re using, rather than Discourse itself ?

I’m using the Light theme so maybe it’s related to that but still that’s a theme that’s shipped by default in discourse and the screenshot is from meta itself :slight_smile:

Can we repro this in the default theme on Android @dax?

1 like

Mmm no, I can’t repro

It seems to work fine for me on Chrome 85.0.4
183.101 and Android 10 using the Light theme.

4 likes

I tried to reproduce but with no avail. I get the same as Dax. However, this used to happen in my tablet (amazon tablet but fireOS is based on android) and I got this issue. However, I have never seen it since.

Some additional notes, I tried on a few more devices and seems like I can only replicate the issue on Samsung devices.

Got same behaviour on 3 Samsung phones but it renders fine on xiaomi/poco devices. So there could be a strong chance that Samsung is doing something funny with either chrome or something else that is causing this.

3 likes

Same on my galaxy s5 :

Android 8, Chrome 85

3 likes

I don’t think it’s related to Samsung devices, now I can see this issue randomly even opening the site on Firefox with my Huawei Mate 20 Pro

2 likes

I’m sorry, I had most consistent repro on my family’s Samsung phones only so I suggested that.

This should fix the issue

https://github.com/discourse/discourse/commit/061ab753430d748044a636cf7c79895152fd1bbe

Thanks for reporting it @itsbhanusharma :+1:

7 likes