Uncategorized Category : looking for a good practice

AI-generated summary

In a discussion about best practices for forum category setup, pixelemotion seeks advice on handling the default Uncategorized category within their main COMMUNITY section. They consider renaming it to “Community” or “General” but are unsure. Johani clarifies whether they meant a topic or category, and pixelemotion confirms it’s the category. Stephen advises disabling the Uncategorized category via the allow uncategorized topics setting in /admin, noting that while renaming is no longer possible, disabling it encourages users to choose appropriate categories — though he personally leaves it enabled to lower barriers for hesitant posters. pixelemotion thanks Stephen and confirms their team has carefully planned categories, with “General” likely serving as the default fallback for users unsure where to post. The consensus leans toward disabling Uncategorized if categories are well-defined, while preserving user flexibility through a broad “General” sub-category.

Hello,

As I am creating categories in our new forum, I want to set them the right way :slight_smile: and have feedback from experienced users.

We will have a main category called COMMUNITY that will probably drive most of the discussions.

In COMMUNITY, we will create sub-categories like :

  • General
  • Show & Tell
  • Jobs
  • etc.

For now I still have this category called Uncategorized and I see this is a “sensitive” one.

  • Should I rename this category to be “community” so that every default conversation be directed there?
  • Or should I rename it to be “General”, a sub-category ?
  • Or neither of these 2 options… maybe there’s a better common & good practice ?

Thanks a lot for your feedback and advices

Hey :wave:

You mentioned this in your post

Are you referring to an actual topic here, or are you referring to the Uncategorized category?

1 Like

Yes sorry I was referring to the Uncategorized category

1 Like

If you think you’ve neatly defined all the boxes that posts will fall in, you can disable the Uncategorized category in /admin. The setting is called allow uncategorized topics. With uncategorized disabled there is no default category, users will then have to pick a category for every post, which makes mis-categorization unlikely.

Renaming Uncategorized had the potential to create confusion, and is no longer possible. Personally I only leave it enabled to encourage users to post even if they can’t see somewhere the topic will fit.

9 Likes

Thanks @Stephen, good suggestion to disable it.

We spent quite some time to think about our categories. And “General” will probably be the default category to choose from, for the most hesitant user.

4 Likes