Unwhispered "split this topic" posted created when whisper replies moved to another topic

סיכום מבוסס בינה מלאכותית

The discussion revolves around an issue where moving whisper replies to a staff-only topic creates a non-whisper “split this topic” post, exposing sensitive information. tobiaseigen notes that this post is visible to all users, potentially compromising privacy, and that deleting it may lose useful staff information. They suggest making the split post a whisper if all replies are whispers. simon confirms the issue occurs on the test site, while codinghorror suggests simply deleting the post as a workaround, questioning the need for special features.

See screenshot - I just moved a few whisper topics from a public post to another topic in a staff-only category, and the “split this topic” reply is added that is not a whisper. I deleted it when I noticed it, but it felt strange. 1) the existence of these posts and the name of the staff-only topic is exposed, 2) when deleted, some info is lost that is of use to staff, 3) I may not notice it and delete it.

Not sure if it’s worth doing something about. Maybe do a check for whispers and if the posts are all replies also make this split post a whisper?

3 לייקים

I can reproduce this on https://try.discourse.org/. The split topic small-post is displayed for all users after moving a whisper to a protected category.

2 לייקים

Just delete the message by pressing the trash icon? I don’t see need for any special one-off features here?

3 לייקים