Hi there guys, I just wondered why GIFs are so small when you upload them - even if you choose 100% as the size E.g [2020-04-07 10.18.45]

What is the size of the GIF you are uploading? The one below is 245x250 and uploads fine. [babies12]

This looks like an error in speficically what you are choosing to upload? Can you describe it exactly, step by step, with examples?

Here is a gif that triggers the issue. When I look at its properties on my computer, its type is set to ‘image/gif’. Its size is 10.4MB. It seems that Discourse is resizing its images. I am able to upload smaller gifs that I created in the same way without any display issues. [featured_topic]

So this is about GIFs that are normally too large to fit the upload limit, they are being auto-resized somehow? That resulting image is tiny: 50 x 29, 32kb Perhaps this is a regression @sam ? :thinking:

Possibly a regression, does this happen with non animated gifs as well?

Thanks guys - I’m using http://giffox.com/ to make gifs. Sometimes it works and sometimes not… I think you might be right about the size. Was just doing some tests Can make it work if it’s very short.

Here is a 2.06 mb GIF [giphy] Here is a 3.47 mb GIF [89952-master-strokes-beard-gif-Kill-bdei] Here is a 9.06 mb GIF [Ton-Sur-Ton-directed-by-REGAN-CAMERON-1080p] Yeah looks like something very bad is happening at the 4mb limit to these @sam @eviltrout . I edited the title to reflect the issu…

Just wanted to confirm this is isolated to animated gifs. I think we use Gifsicle: Command-Line Animated GIFs for resizing do my guess is that params changed @vinothkannans can you have a quick look today

https://github.com/discourse/discourse/commit/b57d4586d713102ce939fd8d17f2ce200f290171 It’s happening since we changed the way of image downsizing . The above commit will fix this issue and the larger gifs will scale down properly. [five]

Is this the correct fix? I don’t think we should be “downsizing” what are effectively videos? That feels like a rather extreme (and possibly very server CPU intensive) manipulation, that could ruin video (gif) quality. I’m not sure about this. I think we should outright reject animated GIFs which a…

4MB 以上のアニメーション GIF をアップロードすると非常に小さく表示される

サポート

vinothkannans (Vinoth Kannan) 2020 年 4 月 10 日午後 12:52 11

これは、画像の縮小の方法を変更してから発生しています。上記のコミットでこの問題が修正され、大きな GIF も適切に縮小されるようになります。

トピック		返信	表示
Animated GIF avatars no longer supported by default Announcements	21	6719	2022 年 3 月 8 日
Emojis from animated gif are shown uglily Bug emoji	11	13817	2015 年 2 月 25 日
Animated user card troubles Support	6	578	2019 年 4 月 30 日
Display Animated Gifs with the Download Remote Image To Local Enabled Feature	12	2215	2018 年 8 月 9 日
GIF size 1.2M but Discourse says - over 4 MB? Support uploads	9	577	2023 年 8 月 29 日

4MB 以上のアニメーション GIF をアップロードすると非常に小さく表示される

関連トピック