Users discuss replacing Discourseâs current âlinkâ icon for sharing posts with a more standardized âshareâ icon (e.g., share-alt), citing better user recognition. bquast initiated the topic, noting the current icon doesnât match modern conventions. manuel tried using api.replaceIcon('link', 'share-alt') but found it ineffective for the share button, unlike for other icons. renato provided the correct solution: replacing d-post-share and d-topic-share instead, which worked for others. bquast initially saw the icon disappear, resolved by Jagster who advised adding share-alt to the svg icon subset in settings. A brief debate arose over whether external-link-alt (suggested by manuel) is semantically appropriate for sharing, with Jagster and bquast arguing that âshareâ better reflects the action, especially since mobile uses OS share UI. renato acknowledged the point after misreading the context. The consensus favors share-alt for clarity and modern UX standards.
On Discourse the share post icon is a link (as in links-in-a-chain) icon. This also works well, but I think nowadays the nodes icon at the top here is most recognized.
It used to be the link icon, but that replaced the link icon where the share icon wouldnât make sense (like on the formatting bar button for adding a link).
I just tested the below and it seems to work as intended:
hmm.. I guess I wouldnât worry that much about an icons âetymologyâ but rather if itâs commonly used in that context. And this seems pretty much the case here, e.g. hereâs a view from twitter:
Well, agree to disagree, I find the share icon a better representation of the action than a link icon, but thatâs just me. Also, if youâre on mobile, this action will actually open the OS share UI, and Iâm pretty sure that the link approach is only used because we donât have a good support for the Web Share API on desktop just yet.
If I understand the comment by @Jagster correctly, he is not arguing against the use of share-alt for the external-link-plus-SM-share popup on desktop / OS share UI on mobile, but rather he saying that since it is a share functionality, using the external link icon wouldnât cover the functionality entirely.