קישורי Vimeo שהועלו לאחר 2020-12-18 מתנגנים ללא שמע ב-ipad באמצעות DiscourseHub

סיכום מבוסס בינה מלאכותית

Users reported that Vimeo videos uploaded after December 18, 2020, played without audio and froze when seeking on iPad via the DiscourseHub app — though videos uploaded before that date worked fine. Nacho_Caballero provided test links and noted the issue didn’t occur on desktop or iPhone. Testing by Don, merefield, and pmusaraj confirmed the bug was iPad-specific and reproducible on DiscourseHub but not Safari or Chrome (which share the same engine on iOS). Vimeo declined to assist, citing lack of support for embedded players in hybrid apps. Despite no console errors found in the webview, pmusaraj noted a device-level error: “Required client entitlement is missing.” Surprisingly, Nacho_Caballero later reported the issue resolved itself, confirmed by pmusaraj, who closed the thread. The root cause remains unknown, but the problem appears to have been fixed by Vimeo or iOS updates.

I don’t know what happened on December 18, 2020, but Vimeo links posted on any Discourse site play without audio when using the iOS DiscourseHub app (at least on iPad, I don’t have an iPhone to test). Also, clicking on the progress bar makes the video permanently freeze.

Videos created before Dec 18 are unaffected by this (I post Vimeo links every day, so I was able to narrow it down to this date).

Here’s an example link without any embed restrictions https://vimeo.com/508864124/fcbbcc92fa. On desktop it plays fine, but if you use the DiscourseHub app on an iPad, there’s no sound and it freezes if you jump forwards/backwards.

Also, some of my users have reported this behavior when using Chrome and Safari on iPad, but using those browsers works well on my iPad.

Tested on iPhone 7 Plus, iOS 14.4, DiscourseHub app. Everything works fine. :slight_smile:

לייק 1

Can you share a link for a post affected and one for an unaffected?

This one works: Vimeo Embed not working on my site due to Vimeo server IP blacklisting - #2 by codinghorror

And the one I just posted is an example that doesn’t work

Thanks for looking into it. It might be an iPad thing then.

2 לייקים

No issue on my iPad mini running iOS 14.4 but can repro on my iPad Pro, weird!

לייק 1

Yeah, I have an iPad Pro on 14.4 Super weird

לייק 1

I can reproduce on iPad on 14.3 and 14.4 on DiscourseHub, no repro on iPhone. No repro on iPad simulator either. Not sure what we can do about it.

לייק 1

I contacted Vimeo and they said they “do not support use of the Vimeo Player within webapps, in-app browsers, or hybrid apps”, so not much help on their part. Some of my users mentioned they also saw the issue using Chrome and Safari. @pmusaraj @merefield I’d be curious to know if you can reproduce on those browsers on the iPad (I couldn’t). That way at least we might get access to a console error.

2 לייקים

No repro on Safari iOS for me. (And Chrome iOS is same as Safari under the hood.)

I can hook up a console log for the DiscourseHub webview on a real device, will try to do that next week and see if anything shows up there.

5 לייקים

Hi Penar,

Were you able to see anything in the console?

לייק 1

Sorry for the delay, Nacho. I just tried this out and I can’t figure it out. There are no errors in the webview console. There is an error in the device console but it’s there whether the audio plays or not (FWIW the error is Required client entitlement is missing.

So, I don’t know what to make of this.

2 לייקים

Thanks for trying anyway!

לייק 1

Actually, I just tried and it seems that Vimeo fixed something because the issue seems to have resolved by itself. :man_shrugging:

לייק 1

Indeed, fixed on my iPad too. Awesome, closing!

לייק 1