In the Post Voting topic, whispers and small action posts (like âclosedâ or âsplitâ) disappear after reloading or revisiting the topic, a known issue in Discourse 3.1.0beta+309. JammyDodger acknowledges the bug, noting it affects both whispers and small action posts due to the post voting layout. nat explains the cause: a filter removes small action posts when sorting by votes, though they are better understood in chronological order (
We use post voting in our community and see the following behaviour: in normal topics, whispers function as intended. In post voting topics, whispers appear immediately after creation, but become invisible after reloading or when visiting the topic again.
This is currently an unfortunate side effect of the post voting layout. A similar thing also happens with small action posts like âclosedâ and âsplitâ too. It is under discussion for how best to handle these, but Iâm afraid I donât have a timeline on when this may be resolved.
When sorting by votes, itâs hard to insert small action posts in between because they tend to be better understood in chronological order (aka âActivityâ). The bug now is that there is a filter that removes small action posts for both sorting methods.
I will remove the filter when âActivityâ is selected, which will allow the small action posts to appear.
Itâs probably also useful to have a site setting that allows admins to set if the preferred sort order is by âVotesâ or âActivityâ, I think?