I don’t think anyone is suggesting this though. We’re saying to rank title matches higher, which is not the scenario you just described. When the title matches the search term, it should specifically boost the rank of the first post, not all posts in the topic.
I disagree with this assessment. Users don’t care about finding posts specifically, but rather about finding content. When topics are properly named, the title is often the best indicator of what the user wants, and most of the time that means starting with the first post.
At least in the community I use, there are topics in certain subcategories that are often searched for for the purpose of sharing the topics when other users ask for help. Getting a random post in the topic from the search results instead of the first post has led to the wrong posts being shared, which has resulted in users not getting help as quickly as they could.
Whether for sharing or for personal use, I also think you’re underestimating how often users just want to search for the same topic over and over again, and I think in those cases, the vast majority of the time the users either want the first post or to continue from where they left off.