Yes, I’ve tried this approach, but think it’s generally not intuitive for users that actually have access to understand that they only can post in the sub-categories. This gets complicated by the fact that the “New Topic”-button will not show when entering the umbrella category. So this needs an additional workaround in the design.
Thanks for the heads up! Well, I just wanted to share this feedback, because I think there’s three basic category modes: Public, Restricted and Secret. Other platforms make it very simple to choose one of those modes. Here’s the setting on circle:
On Discourse we have Public and Secret. And the Private/Restricted mode defaults to what @Heliosurge mentioned: View the category topics, but no post/reply. But that setup is a rather rare requirement, as it is typically already covered by not being logged in to a site.
I think the more common default for Private/Restricted would be just the category page with a lock and a description.
