The discussion revolves around moving the edit icon in a table from the top left to the top right. Canapin argues that placing the edit icon on the right is preferable because it’s less likely to obscure text, especially given left-aligned content and the common right alignment of other interactive elements in the interface. Jordan Vidrine initially raises a concern about potentially hiding text on the right, but Canapin counters that this is less likely and points to the consistent right alignment of other UI actions. Jordan Vidrine ultimately agrees with Canapin’s reasoning.
It will almost always hide information, whereas it’s likely that there will be less information on the top right, even with a full-width table (because the text is aligned to the left; RTL languages needs to be considered):
The reason this button only shows on hover is so the text can be easily readable unless you are wanting to go in and edit it. I don’t think any change is required here.
That’s right, but isn’t less likely to hide text to the right most of the time?
Plus, most of posts interactive elements are aligned to the right: the share link, the revision history, all the posts’ actions (like, reply, edit, etc.),
the copy button from the blockquote: