"1 new or updated topic" on user's topic list page after straight after replying

סיכום מבוסס בינה מלאכותית

Users report a persistent issue where, after replying to a topic and immediately returning to the topics list, a notification appears indicating “1 new or updated topic”—even though no actual unread content exists. This occurs consistently across multiple Discourse versions and is reproducible when closing a topic and returning to the list. While some users consider it a minor annoyance or working as designed, others find it confusing, especially when using keyboard shortcuts to return to the list. The issue appears to be related to timing and caching, with suggestions that the system incorrectly flags a topic as updated after a reply. Some users suspect it may be linked to server load or race conditions, though it’s not consistently reproducible. Despite being discussed for years, the problem remains unresolved, with developers acknowledging it’s tricky to fix due to maintaining scroll position and cache behavior. Chili first reported the issue, and others like watchmanmonitor, kensims, and Geoffrey_Challen confirm it, noting it’s a common workflow for frequent contributors.

I apologise if this has been covered before, I’ve looked but I have not seen this talked about. It has been happening since as long as I can remember.

  1. Read to bottom of topic
  2. Type a reply and as soon as you finish and click “Reply” immediately return to the main list of topics.
  3. The user is given the notification that there is a new/updated topic at the top.

  1. When user clicks that item the the topic list is refreshed but there are no new notifications next to any topic.

(also works when submitting a new topic)

I am using Chrome, and we are on the latest version of Discourse 1.4b3 (although it has happened consistently through several versions). As such I’m not sure it classifies as a “bug” but it can be confusing to users.

3 לייקים

I’ve posted a lot, and on a lot of discourses.. and have never seen that. (I’m also using Chrome)

How many people click on the list immediately after posting?

It’s a timing issue, and I don’t really think it’s worth fixing.

I’ve seen that more than I would like to in the past few months. This is even easier to reproduce when you close a topic and then go back to the topics list. The automated message that is posted on your behalf should not generate a notification.

2 לייקים

I think it is worth fixing, but its a bit tricky to fix, after you reply we got to poison the “back” cache. But then … the issue is that we still got to maintain scroll position, so its tricky .. cc @eviltrout

לייק 1

I see it all the time because I open the topic in another tab. After I’ve posted a reply and closed the tab so that I’m back at the list, there’s the notification.

While it may be confusing, I consider it to be WAD (Working As Designed).

Here’s what I got after making that post …

Having nothing else unread, when I clicked on the notification I got …

לייק 1

I do, every time. I answer a lot of topics, so the typical workflow is to enter a topic, read to the end, write and post a reply, hit the logo in the top left to go back to the topic list. Then get the “1 new or updated”, every time. :confused:

3 לייקים

Aaaand just like that, I saw the flash here on meta after my last post. I don’t think I did anything different than what I’ve done in the past, but sure enough, I flashed myself.

Very late to this topic, but I came here to report the same behavior, which has been happening in Discourse as long as I’ve been using it.

I use the keyboard shortcuts, so it’s usually:

  1. Reply
  2. gh to go home
  3. (…wait for it…)
  4. “1 new or updated topic”

Only a mild annoyance, but surprising that this is still open after all these years…

It happends with Hub/iPad sometimes — perhaps every 10th time I write here. But because I’m not that active I didin’t react — it will disappear after some time anyway.

But… I’ve experienced it only here. Not on my own setup, or on any other forums where I’m doing something more than just lurking. So my very-uneducated-guess is it is related to load, rushtime, or anything else when happends too many things at same time. Ot it just happends sometime :wink:

There is possibility too that I’m just talking about similar, but totally different incident than everyone else.