Hello,
If I might add some light here. In certain gaming communities keeping your roster a secret is very important. This is both to hide you own size and strength as well as protect double agents. Hiding the users page is a great help in protecting the guild. That all make sense so far?
The badges are awesome for adding achievements as well as personal character to members. the issue now though is with the links to all members with that badge enabled we have just gone back to revealing our member lsists and thus our guild security will be compromised.
So my point is I appreciate I can hide the user page now, but please allow us the ability to hide our users thru other pages on the site such as the badges.
Thank you for the consideration.