Hi there, I’m working on trying to migrate a google group to a Discourse forum and am having some issues with HTML being posted in emails. The mailing list is for a web framework, so folks posting HTML back and forth is pretty common. Since the emails we’re trying to import were coming from a system that didn’t support markdown, these HTML segments wouldn’t include code fences around them and there are too many to manually edit. As a compromise, I’d like to disable HTML entities in posts completely. While searching the forum for this I saw @codinghorror mention that @eviltrout added a mode where this was possible, but I couldn’t find the magic setting in my admin panel. Does anyone know how to flip Discourse into this mode? Thanks!

Yeah the new markdown engine has a rule for dealing with HTML tags it could be replaced in a plugin, but what you would have at the end of the process is not CommonMark, it is some sort of mister hydra

Without thinking about it too hard, I think that the thing to do might be to encode the HTML tags before the import. It sounds like it might be safe enough to just convert all of the s into <s and >s.

You could also modify the import script to pass the body through a filter at that point.

That’s true. Although I’ll admit I’m also concerned about folks interacting with our community via email. Including HTML without a fence should, ideally, only render uncolored HTML. Anything else will likely cause frustration.

Oh. That’s a bigger problem. I have a BS in computer science and a PhD in education. I have learned that programming people is lots harder than programming computers.

There’s no mode to disable HTML entities that I recall. There is a type of post you can mark as HTML (see the mbox importer for an example) and no cooking or processing will be done.

Got it. I don’t think that would be desirable either. What I really need is something that, upon seeing raw HTML in a post, will escape the HTML before the Markdown processor converts Markdown to HTML. In poking around the code I noticed that there’s a tags whitelist of sorts, so I could see just disabling that as a possibility. Or, potentially, preprocessing the text before the markdown processor runs. Are either of these doable in the form of a plugin? Thanks!

Yeah, that’s unfortunate but for certain communities I think the trade off would be worth it. Thanks!

Disabling HTML entities in posts

Product Support

farmdawgnation (Matt Farmer) July 8, 2017, 3:45pm 3

The problem is these are mbox files so that transformation would have to try and distinguish between parts of the mbox and HTML.

Topic		Replies	Views
HTML Entities and escape characters in text/plain outgoing email alternative Bug	7	869	January 14, 2024
Wordpress plugin and html-as-text (especially for mail) WordPress	7	1041	October 5, 2022
How do I disable Markdown completely? Product Support	19	2973	August 17, 2016
Incoming HTML Email Inconsistent Product Support	4	1106	September 4, 2017
Idea: Option to always linkify untagged URLs in imported HTML Feature	3	462	January 23, 2023

Disabling HTML entities in posts

Related topics