Hey all,
Is it possible to set up multiple Topic Timers – for example: publish, and then a separate one to auto-close the thread. I have a direct need for this…it’s not a deal breaker for it not to exist…just automation is amazing.
1 Mi Piace
Is this what you’re after?
Auto-closing is already core.
1 Mi Piace
Not possible right now as we only allow one public topic timer (publish, closing, opening) per topic. As a workaround now, you could set a publish topic timer and add a reminder for yourself to close the topic.
Could you build on your use case a little as to why you have a need for multiple topic timers? Multiple topic timers is not impossible but tricky to deal with as we now have to make sure that there isn’t any overlap with the time range.
4 Mi Piace
I pretty much wanted a publish timer and a timer to close the topic automatically…not much more to it.
3 Mi Piace
Here’s my use case for two topic timers on the same topic.
In my community, we have a recurring weekly topic called Wow Us Wednesday. It’s a 24 hour period for members to do self-promotion as we’ve found they need a time and place to vent their promotional steam.
We use the existing topic timer functionality to automatically close the topic 24 hours after being published – mostly so promotion stays contained to a specific weekly time frame and doesn’t keep bubbling back up to the top all the time.
However, using the auto close topic timer prohibits me from using the schedule publishing topic timer – and I want to use both.
I would prefer to schedule 4-8 weekly Wow Us Wednesday topics all at once from an efficiency perspective. Right now, I can’t use the schedule publishing topic timer as my one topic timer because, if I miss my window to manually close the topic 24 hours after it’s published, members can do self-promotion beyond our 24 hour concentrated time frame.
Since our Wow Us Wednesday takes place from 12:00 a.m. PDT - 11:59 p.m. PDT and I’m two hours ahead in CDT, I’d have to wake up at 2:00 a.m. to manually close the topic – something I’m not keen to do. That says nothing of my changed responsibilities if I’m on vacation, sick, or can’t find another admin in a different time zone to manually close the topic.
Having two topic timers on the same topic wouldn’t be revolutionary for me. But it would sure make my scheduling and team coordination easier, and I imagine hundreds of other Discourse users would say the same.
8 Mi Piace
Interesting use case.
I think there is totally merit for supporting “delay published, auto closing” topics. I can see use cases where it is useful.
A current workaround is to post it to a category with auto-close topic hours set, would that not work?
5 Mi Piace
I appreciate the workaround suggestion, Sam. I could see it working for some Discourse users … the issue is it doesn’t work for mine.
The self-promotion threads are published to a category called “Anything Goes” and the nature of the category is to have wide-ranging conversations. The only forum threads in the category I’d want to auto-close are the self-promotion focused ones I publish. The rest are published by community members and I want to leave replies open indefinitely.
Granted, I could create a new category specifically for these weekly self-promotion posts. But we’re wary of the communication and UX tradeoffs when we create new categories and try to do it as infrequently as possible.
2 Mi Piace
How about a “wow us Wednesday” subcategory of “anything goes”?
3 Mi Piace
Stephen, we played with the idea of having a “Wow Us Wednesday” sub-category of the “Anything Goes” master category. However, despite the efficiency gain of being able to have a dedicated sub-category with the ability to auto-close all topics in it after 24 hours, we weren’t willing to make the trade off in UX.
For example, having a sub-category filter in the Anything Goes category for the Wow Us Wednesday sub-category and seeing the standalone Wow Us Wednesday sub-category on the the Categories view page (e.g., https://yourforum.com/categories) draws too much attention to the fact that we have a dedicated sub-category for self-promotion.
Our goal is to limit the visibility of self-promotion for the 144 out of the 168 hours each week where we’re not actively doing self-promotion.
I’m grateful for the suggestion. I’ll just wait until @sam or someone else on the Discourse Team develops the “delay published, auto closing” feature Sam mentioned he’d like to see.
3 Mi Piace
Did you experiment with hiding that particular subcategory from /categories using css?
I have another use case for publish-then-close: I am running a course, where we are posting announcements inviting input for each course activity, and afterwards closing the announcement after the corresponding activity (lecture or Q&A) is over. An auto-close category wouldn’t quite work because different activities have different expiration.
3 Mi Piace
Hi, tried to setup multiple timers for recurring events. Allowing 2 - 3 would be useful!
- Delayed Publish
- Delete All Replies after 7 days
- Auto Bump weekly, or bi-weekly, before the event recurs.
Thanks for considering. Also using new automation plugin to:
Auto-Pin topic the day before next occurrence. Hoping to eventually set this as recurring weekly / bi-weekly / monthly rather than on a specific day. ← This how we’ve configured our Event plugin.
Perhaps there could be more interplay between topic timers and the automation plugin in the future. Cheers.
Another topic timer option that could be useful:
- Remove all emoticons from topic.
This is because users like to use emoticons to interact with a topic when they agree / disagree, etc.
2 Mi Piace
That belongs in the event plugin IMO.
2 Mi Piace
Il mio caso d’uso è per i thread di gioco.
Voglio lanciare il thread BLOCCATO a mezzanotte perché la gente inizierà a cercarlo dal nostro blog dell’evento della durata di una settimana. Questo posso farlo.
Voglio impostarlo per sbloccarlo alle 9:00 quando il gioco inizia effettivamente. L’unico modo per farlo è restare alzato dopo mezzanotte per impostare un altro timer o farlo manualmente alle 9:00.
Un altro caso d’uso sono i thread dei giveaway. Mi piacerebbe inviare gli orari di avvio e chiusura contemporaneamente invece di aspettare che venga avviato per impostare l’ora di fine.
MI PIACEREBBE MOLTO impostare due timer. Vedo dove questo diventa un po’ complicato se entrano in conflitto, ma forse limitare i casi d’uso o inserire alcuni controlli e bilanciamenti.
Grazie!
5 Mi Piace
Sarebbe utile dividerlo in una RFE specifica per i post programmati che si chiudono automaticamente?
La soluzione alternativa di avere una categoria a chiusura automatica ha senso in generale, ma voglio farlo per un insieme specifico di conversazioni come parte di una discussione strutturata nei prossimi mesi, e l’impostazione di una categoria separata sembra eccessiva per questo.
Perché non semplicemente configurarlo come una sottocategoria separata? Non è poi così male, e puoi configurarlo in modo che i tuoi utenti probabilmente nemmeno se ne accorgano.
I miei utenti notano molto. 
Molti hanno impostato filtri per ordinare le loro e-mail di notifica e sono quindi sensibili ai cambiamenti di categoria.
Inoltre, non sono sicuro di come funzionino le impostazioni di notifica per le sottocategorie… se ne creo una, erediterà dalla categoria principale per gli utenti esistenti o dovranno iscriversi separatamente?
Uggh!!! Devi spostarli dalla modalità mailing list e farli passare all’interfaccia utente di Discourse! Non è facile, lo so per esperienza diretta. Buona fortuna.
I tag dell’oggetto dell’email includeranno il nome della categoria padre, ma dipenderà da come hanno impostato i loro filtri (in particolare se includono entrambe le parentesi quadre).
È un po’ complesso - c’è una funzionalità di ereditarietà quando si impostano le impostazioni predefinite di notifica, ma non ci ho trafficato. Puoi sicuramente impostarle indipendentemente se lo desideri.